Go back
what if a future world chess champion....

what if a future world chess champion....

General

G

santa cruz, ca.

Joined
19 Jul 13
Moves
376505
Clock
04 Sep 21

was a strong nazi sympathizer and white supremacist
what do you think should happen?

IP

Joined
15 Jun 10
Moves
47094
Clock
04 Sep 21

@lemondrop said
was a strong nazi sympathizer and white supremacist
what do you think should happen?
He/she should be made to play with the black pieces, then he/she would see that all pieces are equal.

Sorry, that was flippant and a bit obvious. An unfortunate result of allowing freedom of thought and speech is that there will always be people with unfortunate attitudes and philosophies. They walk amongst us. I daresay that if the bloke who was sent to put out the fire if ones' house was burning down was a Nazi sympathizer, one would wish him to put the fire out anyway. We must live with them, unfortunately, and try to live good lives ourselves.

G

santa cruz, ca.

Joined
19 Jul 13
Moves
376505
Clock
05 Sep 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

should a person convicted of rape or child molestation be allowed to play at an international level?

G

santa cruz, ca.

Joined
19 Jul 13
Moves
376505
Clock
05 Sep 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

when do you say no or strip them of the title

G

Joined
16 Aug 15
Moves
1245
Clock
05 Sep 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

@lemondrop said
was a strong nazi sympathizer and white supremacist
what do you think should happen?
BTDTDIA
Google Alekhine

moonbus
Über-Nerd (emeritus)

Joined
31 May 12
Moves
8703
Clock
05 Sep 21

@lemondrop said
was a strong nazi sympathizer and white supremacist
what do you think should happen?
People who hold certain political opinions, particularly racist opinions, Should be barred from holding certain jobs, or removed from those jobs if they already hold those jobs. Examples include policeman and judges, and those involved in law-enforcement generally. The reason why is so obvious it should not have to be stated. However, for other reasons which are so obvious they should not have to be stated, We cannot prevent people who hold such opinions from holding other jobs and even positions within the state, including legislators. It is an extraordinarily difficult balancing act between social justice on the one hand, and individual liberty on the other.

Since a chess player is generally not in a position to inflict grave injustice upon people on account of his racist views, I see no reason to bar him from playing in international competitions or strip him of any title he might achieve. On the other hand, I could well understand players who would refuse to play against him.

moonbus
Über-Nerd (emeritus)

Joined
31 May 12
Moves
8703
Clock
05 Sep 21

@gambrel said
BTDTDIA
Google Alekhine
Fischer too held some pretty unsavory political views.

Very Rusty
Treat Everyone Equal

Halifax, Nova Scotia

Joined
04 Oct 06
Moves
639178
Clock
05 Sep 21
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

@moonbus said
Fischer too held some pretty unsavory political views.
Fisher just lost it, went a little mental in the end.

https://www.quora.com/What-was-Bobby-Fischers-mental-illness

-VR

G

Joined
16 Aug 15
Moves
1245
Clock
09 Sep 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

@Very-Rusty
It's not unheard of for chess geniuses to lose it. Paul Morphy for one. I remember reading some GM lost it, went on a public bus nude. I don't remember who though.

IP

Joined
15 Jun 10
Moves
47094
Clock
09 Sep 21
Vote Up
Vote Down

@gambrel said
@Very-Rusty
It's not unheard of for chess geniuses to lose it. Paul Morphy for one. I remember reading some GM lost it, went on a public bus nude. I don't remember who though.
Well maybe you have to be a bit 'out there' to be a chess genius. I'm glad I'm just an ordinary chess player with no hint of genius, that way at least I get to keep my clothes on whilst riding an omnibus.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.