Go back
Yet another moral dilemma

Yet another moral dilemma

General

Acolyte
Now With Added BA

Loughborough

Joined
04 Jul 02
Moves
3790
Clock
05 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Suppose you're organising an organ donation programme, and someone comes to you and says I want my organs to be available for donation when I die, on condition that they only get transplanted into white people. How would you respond?

s

England

Joined
15 Nov 03
Moves
33497
Clock
05 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acolyte
Suppose you're organising an organ donation programme, and someone comes to you and says I want my organs to be available for donation when I die, on condition that they only get transplanted into white people. How would you respond?
I would be a bit diplomatic and say to the person its not possible to determin where the organ goes due to the matching system. But my thoughts would be i hope they go to someone in need no matter what culture.

f
Quack Quack Quack !

Chesstralia

Joined
18 Aug 03
Moves
54533
Clock
05 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

it sounds like the dude doesn't even have a heart to transplant !!!

V
Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined
20 Jan 03
Moves
14580
Clock
05 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Acolyte
Suppose you're organising an organ donation programme, and someone comes to you and says I want my organs to be available for donation when I die, on condition that they only get transplanted into white people. How would you respond?
This in fact did happen and there was a bit of a furore about it. It was a few years ago at Northern General Hospital in Sheffield:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/652132.stm
In practice they would probably go to a white person anyway, since there is a vastly superior chance of the organ being a correct match if it from a donor belonging to the same ethnic group.

b
Bill

Perth West Australia

Joined
09 Apr 03
Moves
31360
Clock
05 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

say sure thing and sign him up , when he is dead who cares what he thinks..... its a bit like the story the young wife who had an extremly rich elderly husband who requested that he would be buried with all his money... when he died a week later the wife fullfilled her husbands last wish... she wrote him a cheque for the full amount and placed it in his coffin as they put him in the ground 😉

I

Joined
26 Jan 04
Moves
462
Clock
05 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down


say sure thing and sign him up , when he is dead who cares what he thinks.....
Raises an legal issue. Just because a person is dead, doesnt mean they dont have rights. Eg your will is still legally binding when you croak😵

V
Thinking...

Odersfelt

Joined
20 Jan 03
Moves
14580
Clock
05 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Itswidetowest
Raises an legal issue. Just because a person is dead, doesnt mean they dont have rights. Eg your will is still legally binding when you croak😵
Actually, you also have to technically be alive for your organs to be of any use 🙂

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.