I know this is discussed before, but it is such a good idea that we should not forget, and I hope this will be possible soon. What about a clan tournament with 4 members. Every clan that wants to join this tournament has to select 4 members. It works the same as a normal tournament, only a match would be a challenge. Let's say the winner gets 30 points, and the runner up 15. Something like that. I love the idea.
Sander
i like the idea ....but i dislike only having a few members from each clan.....that does not represent your clan completely your clan is made up of the members not just 4 people....take losing is an art for example both dantes and seadevil are in this clan but that clan isnt the best one is it?
Originally posted by TDR1the 4 members was just an example. If you play with 14 members, it is also okay by me, but then not very many clans can play in such clantournament. You always could set max average rating so many clans can play a good tournament.
i like the idea ....but i dislike only having a few members from each clan.....that does not represent your clan completely your clan is made up of the members not just 4 people....take losing is an art for example both dantes and seadevil are in this clan but that clan isnt the best one is it?
- Joined
- 26 Apr 03
- Moves
- 26771
Originally posted by tejoHow about if each group in the tournament was a clan vs clan battle involving two randomly selected remaining clans, with group size equal to the number of players in the smallest clan of the two?
the 4 members was just an example. If you play with 14 members, it is also okay by me, but then not very many clans can play in such clantournament. You always could set max average rating so many clans can play a good tournament.
This sounds like a bit more work to set up, as group sizes in a given round would not be all the same (but they aren't even completely the same at the moment, so I thought it might be ok...?)
Originally posted by iamatigerThe only problem is that every member should be available to play a couple of challenges or set his status to unavailable. One other point is that the clan with most members can just select his best players, so that wouldn't be completely fair. I suggest teams of a certain amount of members with the average rating. I think this would be most fair.
How about if each group in the tournament was a clan vs clan battle involving two randomly selected remaining clans, with group size equal to the number of players in the smallest clan of the two?
This sounds like a bit more work to set up, as group sizes in a given round would not be all the same (but they aren't even completely the same at the moment, so I thought it might be ok...?)
Originally posted by tejoDo you mean that the average rating of the team should be no higher than the average rating of the clan? That would seem fair.
I suggest teams of a certain amount of members with the average rating. I think this would be most fair.
Such a tournament would definitely be fun. Would it be best as a knockout, groups of N or all play all? The rule about clans with members in common might mean a knockout was best, but could still give problems in a later round...
I didn't mean that, but that could also be fun. The way I see this clantournament, is nothing more than a team based tournament, so maybe not just clans should be able to play, but also a team that consist of players who would like to play together in a team. It is not necessary that this tournament will be the way to know which clan is best. That is also not in challenges. It is just another way to earn points, or compete with other clans. So in my opinion you can do 2 things with clantournaments. One for the clans, and two for all kinds of teams.
Sander
If anything like this does happen I think it would be best NOT to award points for the winners / runners up. Not all clans would be able to participate and surely just the honour of winning should be enough.
An analolgy, related to football (soccer) would be that it would be like awarding league table points to the winners of the FA Cup!
Andrew
Originally posted by RussA clan league sounds very good to me. I will be happy to wait with the clantournament until the clan league is operational.😀
It is possible (most things are), but it would take some time to design and code.
I think a clan league is currently more important. But once that it complete, then clan tournaments would be the obvious next feature to add.
-Russ