02 Mar '05 09:34>
For posts about religion.
Originally posted by darvlayMe too. It'll be interesting to see how and if this works. I honestly hope it does. Will it flourish with real debates and discussions or will it become a barren wasteland consisting of nothing but religious zealots spouting off about their faith in the lord until no one longer listens and then they too dissapear?
Well, I'll be damned.
Originally posted by wibreligious zealots spouting off about their faith in the lord until no one longer listens and then they too dissapear?
Me too. It'll be interesting to see how and if this works. I honestly hope it does. Will it flourish with real debates and discussions or will it become a barren wasteland consisting of nothing but religious zealots spouting off about their faith in the lord until no one longer listens and then they too dissapear?
We shall see.
Originally posted by DoctorScribblesPosts and threads will be dealt with case to case... if a subject gets a religious reply, that might just be fine... but if it changes the topic, and becomes too much... the posts will either need to be removed, or the thread might need to be moved if it turns into a religious debate.
Is spiritual discussion in the Debates forum now an alertable offense?
That is, is all spiritual discussion that takes place on RHP required to take place here, or do users have the option of having such discussion in General or Debates?
If a Debate starts to discuss the explicative power of the theory of evolution, are users now prohibited fro ...[text shortened]... ricity of Jesus' miracles as depicted in the Bible no longer a valid topic in Debates?
Dr. S
Originally posted by PhlabibitIt is a failure by design. No implementation can make it a success.
Let's wait for this new forum to fail, before we call it a failure.
P
Originally posted by DoctorScribblesIf you need to ask you're not ready to hear the answer...
Is spiritual discussion in the Debates forum now an alertable offense?
That is, is all spiritual discussion that takes place on RHP required to take place here, or do users have the option of having such discussion in General or Debates?
If a Debate starts to discuss the explicative power of the theory of evolution, are users now prohibited fro ...[text shortened]... ricity of Jesus' miracles as depicted in the Bible no longer a valid topic in Debates?
Dr. S
Originally posted by DoctorScribblesWell I am absolutely nobody of authority on this but I think much more is being made out of all of this than necessary. By myself and others, we felt there was a religious agenda flooding the common Debates arena. As we felt it was unfair that was the case, it was equally unfair to attempt to ban religious discussions, hence the creation of the Spirituality forum. This is where common sense should take over:
Is spiritual discussion in the Debates forum now an alertable offense?
That is, is all spiritual discussion that takes place on RHP required to take place here, or do users have the option of having such discussion in General or Debates?
If a Debate starts to discuss the explicative power of the theory of evolution, are users now prohibited fro ...[text shortened]... ricity of Jesus' miracles as depicted in the Bible no longer a valid topic in Debates?
Dr. S
Originally posted by DoctorScribblesCan't we just see how it goes? Overtly 'spiritual' threads should start here. If non-spiritual threads in 'Debates' turn spiritual, I guess the person/people responsible for the change are asked to take it to 'Spirituality'.
It is a failure by design. No implementation can make it a success.
Either it's mandatory or voluntary. If it's mandatory, my points above stand. If it's voluntary, then it's aesthetically redundant with Debates.
Originally posted by Joe FistSurely you jest in your reasoning and your conclusion. You just can't be serious.
[b]Is the historicity of Jesus' miracles as depicted in the Bible no longer a valid topic in Debates?
This seems to be the only one of what you mentioned that would be, to me, clearly held in the Spirituality forum. With all due respect, not everyone believes in the miracles of Jesus.
[/b]