Originally posted by greenpawn34
I've used this game on my site.
Had no idea the authenticty was in doubt.
Post a link.
Underneath the game, is a reference to Winters among other things.
(Be sure to look at both pages of kibitzing.)
The game is also not in the book The Chess Games Of Adolph Anderssen by Pickard (which is supposed to include them all).
They also make a reference to Winters in the kibitzing.
After a brief (very brief) search at the Winters site. Here is one (of probably many) of the search results.
(See 3885 and 3888)
I'm sure there's more.
This just brings about the question of its authenticity (not the proof).