01 Oct '07 22:04>2 edits
This follows up on Thread 78052 about Game 4064642. Please feel free to comment on anything on the game. I'll start a post on the endgame, that is probably the most interesting part of this game.
15.h3 Whte plays it safely, denying g4 as a pivot point for black in a possible attack on the kingside.
15...Nd7 This move may have many purposes. Black might continue with an attack on the kingside (after all white just weakened his castle) through something like f5. At the same time, black can just be there luooking at what will happen on the queenside, and the knight can switch there if needed.
16.Nb5 White occupies his outpost. This is probably fine and playable, but there were other options to take into account. One was to occupy b5 with the bishop instead. The bishop in c4 is acting like a big fat pawn, and on b5 he would have had more open lines. It still seems to me that the knight is preferable. It gains a tempo on the queen, and the pawn in c5 is fixed not allowing black to try to reduce his crampiness. Antoher option was to seek counterplay in the center, via Re1.
16...Qb8 The queen has to move, but Qb7 looked a bit better because it would have left b8 for the rook.
17.Ra3 A problem with the knight not being in b2 anymore is that b2 needs to be defended. Qc2 looke a natural developing move here, protecting both e4 and b2, freeing the c1 bishop and going towards connecting the rooks. This manouver of the rook is instead a bit clumsy, although probably playable.
17...Nb6 Attacking the bishop and seeking exchanges. It might sound strange that black is ready to exchange his knight for white's poor bishop, but black hi cramped and exchanges favors him. And white's bishop can became strong in the future if white starts playing in the center an menage to play e5, d6 at some point.
18.Qe2 White is ready to replace the bishop with the queen, and develop a piece in the meantime.
18...Nxc4 19.Qxc4 Ba6 Pinning the knight to the queen.
15.h3 Whte plays it safely, denying g4 as a pivot point for black in a possible attack on the kingside.
15...Nd7 This move may have many purposes. Black might continue with an attack on the kingside (after all white just weakened his castle) through something like f5. At the same time, black can just be there luooking at what will happen on the queenside, and the knight can switch there if needed.
16.Nb5 White occupies his outpost. This is probably fine and playable, but there were other options to take into account. One was to occupy b5 with the bishop instead. The bishop in c4 is acting like a big fat pawn, and on b5 he would have had more open lines. It still seems to me that the knight is preferable. It gains a tempo on the queen, and the pawn in c5 is fixed not allowing black to try to reduce his crampiness. Antoher option was to seek counterplay in the center, via Re1.
16...Qb8 The queen has to move, but Qb7 looked a bit better because it would have left b8 for the rook.
17.Ra3 A problem with the knight not being in b2 anymore is that b2 needs to be defended. Qc2 looke a natural developing move here, protecting both e4 and b2, freeing the c1 bishop and going towards connecting the rooks. This manouver of the rook is instead a bit clumsy, although probably playable.
17...Nb6 Attacking the bishop and seeking exchanges. It might sound strange that black is ready to exchange his knight for white's poor bishop, but black hi cramped and exchanges favors him. And white's bishop can became strong in the future if white starts playing in the center an menage to play e5, d6 at some point.
18.Qe2 White is ready to replace the bishop with the queen, and develop a piece in the meantime.
18...Nxc4 19.Qxc4 Ba6 Pinning the knight to the queen.