Calling all geniuses

Originally posted by RECUVIC
unfortunately the whole point has been missed here! white--5/pawn to d4 wins immediately for white! nobody should really need this explained,neither does anybody require micro- brain assistance !!

i think perhaps what is meant is if perfect play from both sides is produced aftet pawn to d4, white will win eventually, so d4 does 'win' eventually, immediately, if u see what i mean. d4 is a winning move, it is up to white to lose the game.

Originally posted by Red Night
No it doesn't!

5. d4 does not win immediately for white.

Not even close.