Go back
Checkmating question

Checkmating question

Only Chess

e

Joined
02 Apr 07
Moves
1368
Clock
17 Feb 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Is it possible to win in a K,R,NvsR,K endgame?

z
Mouth for war

Burlington, KY

Joined
10 Jan 04
Moves
60789
Clock
17 Feb 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

If you have a Knight, then there's always a forking oppurtunity. Granted I don't like the odds but it is possible.

M

St. Paul, Minnesota

Joined
26 Mar 08
Moves
74043
Clock
17 Feb 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by endgamer
Is it possible to win in a K,R,NvsR,K endgame?
yes, but I think your question is it possible to force checkmate. I don't know the answer to that question.

c
Grammar Nazi

Auschwitz

Joined
03 Apr 06
Moves
44348
Clock
17 Feb 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Although I'm not positive, I can say im 99.98% sure it cannot be forced.

z
Mouth for war

Burlington, KY

Joined
10 Jan 04
Moves
60789
Clock
17 Feb 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

I'm fairly sure it could, but it may take too many moves and the opponent could most likely claim a draw before it happened.

KnightStalker47

Joined
12 Nov 06
Moves
74414
Clock
17 Feb 09
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

If there is no immediate way to win material, it is a draw with best play from both sides.

E3

Joined
29 Jun 05
Moves
6907
Clock
17 Feb 09
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by endgamer
Is it possible to win in a K,R,NvsR,K endgame?
From Wikipedia : -
"Rook and a knight versus a rook: this is a theoretical draw, but Judit Polgar lost a famous game to Garry Kasparov when she blundered in a quickplay finish (a sudden death time control) (Nunn 2007:159–61,165). There are five cases that are wins when the defending king is restricted to the edge of the board (Grivas 2008:257)."
Game was in 1996.

AttilaTheHorn
Erro Ergo Sum

In the Green Room

Joined
09 Jul 07
Moves
526232
Clock
17 Feb 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

According. to the book Fundamental Chess Endings by Muller and Lamprecht, it is a draw. However their opinion is that it is worth playing on if the defending king is confined near the edge of the board. If it is in the corner, the chances of winning are good. The game J. Polgar-Kasparov mentioned in an earlier post was referred to.

M

Joined
06 May 08
Moves
1908
Clock
17 Feb 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

For fun, the game in question:

http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1070866

BH

Joined
25 Apr 06
Moves
10474
Clock
17 Feb 09
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

gameid=5999430?

Checkmate 🙄

Edit: never mind, noticed too late that this is a riddle...

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.