Go back
Did Black have a win?

Did Black have a win?

Only Chess

Vote Up
Vote Down

Game 549927

Before 36. h4, that is.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Uhm,still in progress......

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by SirLoseALot
Uhm,still in progress......
It's over now, anyway. But the conclusion was pretty much on the wall after h4. The question (phrased alternatively) - what move for white on 36 could've saved the game?

Vote Up
Vote Down

It's a rook + pawn ending where black is a pawn up,there is no one move solution.When played correct,these endgames most often end in a draw.But a pawn is a pawn,so black has winning chances.
All I can think of is instead of 37.h4 white could have tried Ke3 or f4 and maybe get a draw,but I'm not sure.
Guess we'll have to wait for some endgame expert to enlighten us 🙂

Sir Lot.

Vote Up
Vote Down

I wonder if white was unaware of the en passant rule.

Speaking of rules, am I right in thinking that castling is forbidden in these cases:

1. on the side where the rook has made a prior move, even if it is back on its original square;

2. when the King passes through a square that is under attack;

3. when the king has made a prior move, even if it is back on its orignal square;

4. when the king would be moving to a square under attack (obviously forbidden by the general rule against moving into check);

5. when the king is in check and trying to use castling to get out of check.

Number (5) in particular is one I am not sure about.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Paul Dirac
I wonder if white was unaware of the en passant rule.

Speaking of rules, am I right in thinking that castling is forbidden in these cases:

1. on the side where the rook has made a prior move, even if it is back on its original square;

2. when the King passes through a square that is under attack;

3. when the king has made a prior move, even if ...[text shortened]... ing to use castling to get out of check.

Number (5) in particular is one I am not sure about.
exactly correct in all of your 5 cases.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Most excellent. I learned the rules in my schoolboy days, but I haven't played any games in the intervening decades. I guess it's kind of like what they say about riding a bicycle. 😏

Vote Up
Vote Down

dislike 8. Bb5 just on principle. develop the g knight for chrissakes. What a waste of a perfectly good tempo.

eeeh... both rooks were nastily inactive toward the endgame.

One should race the king towards the side where one has a problem. Although, really, if you're racing the king somewhere in a rook+pawn endgame, you're already screwed, in my experience.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Black wins no matter what White moves after 36