Originally posted by EmLasker
Did the Soviet Dominance start with Alekhine or Botvinnik?
I believe Alekhine. people categorize him as French, but he was really Russian. what's your opinion?
Alekhine was allowed to leave Russia in the 1920s -- with his Swiss wife -- for a visit to the West. He never returned. After he won the world championship from Capablanca in 1927, I'm sure it was a source of consternation that the chess champion of the world had fled the Soviet Union. The Soviet chess establishment shouldered on without the champion and developed its own talent, including one promising candidate: Botvinnik. After he was properly seasoned and had tested his mettle against the best chess players of the West, including Flohr, Reshevsky and Fine, the Soviet authorities approached Alekhine for a title match against the Soviet champion, Botvinnik, to be played in Moscow. According to accounts, Alekhine was very excited at the prospect of returning to his home country and being feted by the Soviet authorities. Alas, it was not to be -- Alekhine died alone in his hotel room in Portugal in 1946.
So in answer to your question, the era of Soviet dominance in chess properly began with Botvinnik. It was only in the 1950s that the Soviets rehabilitated Alehkhine and acknowledged his influence on Soviet chess players. In their book entitled "The Soviet School of Chess," Kotov and Yudovich, the pedigree of Soviet chess begins with Chigorin, then Alekhine and finally, Botvinnik.