Originally posted by robbie carrobie
Based on reading the excellent "The Survival Guide to Rook Endings" by John Emms...
What does White want?
- to reach the Lucena position (as mentioned by Wilfriedva)
[FEN "6K1/4k1P1/8/8/8/8/7r/5R2 w - - 0 0"]
1. Re1+ {White's king needs to escape so the Black king is checked out of the way} Kd7 {Now if the White king tries to escape, the Black rook will keep checking it - so we need to prepare some cover} 2. Re4 Rh1 3. Kf7 Rf1+ 4.Kg6 Rg1+ 5. Kf6 {If it were White's move now, he would play Re5 followed by Rg5} Rf1+ {Kd6 is best but first need to understand the simple ideas} 6. Kg5 Rg1+ 7.Rg4 {White wins}
What does Black want?
- to prevent White obtaining the Lucena position by using
The Frontal Defence. Whenever the pawn is NOT far advanced, keep in mind "The Frontal Defence" possibility.
[FEN "8/8/8/4k3/6K1/5R2/6P1/7r b - - 0 2"]
2... Rh8 {The Black rook is going to keep checking from the front} 3. Rf5+ { White uses his own rook as cover} Ke6 4. g3 Rg8+ 5. Rg5 {Rxg5 is now a lost endgame for Black} Rh8 {While the White rook is protecting the king from checks, it cannot also stop Kf6 when the Black king then helps to oppose the pawn - drawn}
Now...
Rook endgames can be baffling. Just when you think you understand a position, change the location of one piece - even by one square - and suddenly everything can change.
I find that it's vital to acknowledge certain features of the position. In this case:
a) the Black king is cut off from the queening square
b) the Black king is far from the queening square (compare it being on e7)
c) the White pawn is not far advanced
d) the Black rook is not well placed on h1
Why do these matter... explaining (a) to (d)...
a) The Black king would be ideally placed in front of the pawn to oppose it's promotion. Being cut off prevents this.
b) Firstly, if there is an exchange of rooks, the Black king wants to be well placed in the pawn endgame and that often means being closer to the queening square. Secondly, if the Black king was on e7, there is this idea:
Black is challenging White's control of the f-file and hence his king will not remain cut off (drawn).
c) The Frontal Defence relies on White not being able to use the pawn as cover.
White to play - drawn. The White king is exposed to the Frontal Defence
But...
White wins regardless of who to move. The White king is covered by the pawn - no Frontal Defence
d) Obviously for the Frontal Defence, the Black rook needs to get in front of the White king by as big a distance as possible.
Finally the game...
[FEN "8/8/8/8/6K1/4kR2/6P1/7r b - - 0 1"]
1... Ke4 2. Rf8 Rh7 {Black aims for a Frontal Defence} 3. Re8+ {Driving the Black king further away. If the Black king had been on e5, avoiding being driven away due to Kf6, the position is drawn} Kd5 {Now the White king can use the f-file, breaking the Frontal Defence} 4. Kf5 Rf7+ 5. Kg6 Rf4 6. Kg5 Rf7 7. g4 {The pawn is now safely advanced - White wins}
In summary, the poor placing of Black's king meant that Black could not take advantage of White's pawn not being far advanced, via the Frontal Defence.