Go back
Has the magic gone?

Has the magic gone?

Only Chess

K

Joined
28 Sep 05
Moves
3669
Clock
20 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

To all those people who were chess players in the glory days, i.e. before computers could wipe the floor with everyone, do you think that chess has lost some of its magic?
By the time I started playing Deep Blue had been sold for parts and I can't help but feel a little sad that I missed out on the days when a move was beautiful rather than just correct.

Krapsparov
Don't baptise cats!!

Manchester

Joined
18 Jun 06
Moves
66061
Clock
20 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

There is no art in a computer though!!
I don't care if I loose to a computer because it does not mean anything - I can't see the point in playing one.
I think the magic still exists in the world of human chess, however, computers do not!!!

J

back in business

Joined
25 Aug 04
Moves
1264
Clock
20 Nov 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

yes. computers are slowly killing the chess. sooner or later there will be a computer which finds a forced win for white on move 1.

O

Joined
11 Sep 06
Moves
17376
Clock
20 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Jusuh
yes. computers are slowly killing the chess. sooner or later there will be a computer which finds a forced win for white on move 1.
I'd be willing to wager heavily against this ever happening. For two reasons, really; one, it would actually have to be able to 'solve' chess (which given the total number of possible positions, will likely never truly be possible - though with pruning it's a somewhat simpler job); and more importantly, because white to move on move 1 is probably a draw. 🙂

s

Joined
27 Oct 06
Moves
538
Clock
20 Nov 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Yes, eventually you'll be able to get a handheld chess computer that plays 3500+ chess at the checkout aisle of your grocery store. True, people will always chess, but devoting serious study to it will seem as quaint as memorizing log tables.

G

Stockholm, Sweden

Joined
31 Jan 06
Moves
3059
Clock
20 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

You can still compete in it, because there is probably no way a human could learn all that theory anyway.

And to me, correctness is beauty =)

w
If Theres Hell Below

We're All Gonna Go!

Joined
10 Sep 05
Moves
10228
Clock
20 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

people still run competatively, regardless of that there's been faster ways to go forth for quite a long time now. hell, we even walk competatively.

V

Joined
21 Sep 05
Moves
27507
Clock
20 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Knightlore
Hypothetically , take a typical chess player and give them access to a computer that plays chess perfectly. Let them study this for 10 years.

Now, take that player and let them play a match against, e.g., Morphy, who obviously didn't get access to such theory.

I know which player my money would be on. Then we'd see the magic of chess versus the myth that memorisation is the key.

P

Joined
11 Oct 06
Moves
13013
Clock
20 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

I really do not like chess engines. For one, they won't let you play games like this:

Game 2781914

g

Joined
22 Aug 06
Moves
359
Clock
20 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Jusuh
yes. computers are slowly killing the chess. sooner or later there will be a computer which finds a forced win for white on move 1.
If computers are "killing" chess, then how come more people than ever are playing it? I believe that computers have helped chess to grow and become more popular.

slickhare
...

Santa Clara, CA

Joined
02 Oct 06
Moves
9225
Clock
21 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

i didn't live in the "glory days" but i don't think computers are ruining chess. computers are computers and men are men. if a computer can figure out how to beat you no matter what, people aren't just going to say "ok game over, not point in playing anymore". it's a computer! i find much more satisfaction in beating a friend than in beating some random free chess engine i salvaged. there's a huge separation in my mind between human chess and computer chess. and since no human person can win ALL THE TIME, then chess will always be the immortal game.

c

Joined
02 Feb 06
Moves
8557
Clock
21 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Piisgood
I really do not like chess engines. For one, they won't let you play games like this:

Game 2781914
Chess engines can play better - and you've posted that game twice now, we've already seen it.

e

Joined
19 Nov 05
Moves
3112
Clock
21 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

No.

This has been another edition of Simple Answers to RHP threads.

A
D_U_N_E

Arrakis

Joined
01 May 04
Moves
64653
Clock
21 Nov 06
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Jusuh
yes. computers are slowly killing the chess. sooner or later there will be a computer which finds a forced win for white on move 1.
Or perhaps a forced win for Black! Because White had to make the first commitment! 😲

v

Joined
04 Jul 06
Moves
7174
Clock
21 Nov 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Yes! maybe at some point the people will decide to remove computers from chess field, and the magic might be back.

Ban computers from chess!!!

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.