04 Sep '10 00:39>
I know some will cringe simply when they read the thread title, but I hope my OP will help a bit. I also have to give some credit to Greenpawn34 for making me think about what makes a good opening book, but he may not want to accept it!
I have many favorite opening books, but two of my all-time favorites are Winning with the King's Gambit by GM Joe Gallagher, and Winning with the French by GM Wolfgang Uhlmann.
Both of these books use the complete annotated game format, with lots of prose and variations given only when they illuminate the game or an idea the author wants to illustrate in detail. In my opinion, this is the formula for a great opening book.
GM Gallagher uses many of his own games in his book, and it has a very personal feel to it. It's almost as though he is sitting down next to you as you read, showing you some great games, and what he thinks about them and the opening in general.
As for GM Uhlmann's book, it is filled with 60 complete annotated French games, and he plays black in every one of them! He is a premier GM and possibly one of the world's greatest French experts, and reading the book is a rare opportunity to "get inside the head" of a world class GM as he shares games and talks about his favorite opening.
I have never played the French, and have no plans to do so, but I felt like a book by a top-flight GM on his favorite opening, demonstrated as complete games, was too good a learning opportunity to pass up.
I have to give an "honorable mention" nod to the first edition of The King's Indian Attack by Ken Smith and John Hall, as I feel like they practically taught me how to play tournament chess 20 years ago, but that's more a personal recollection, and the books above are in a different and higher class.
Paul
I have many favorite opening books, but two of my all-time favorites are Winning with the King's Gambit by GM Joe Gallagher, and Winning with the French by GM Wolfgang Uhlmann.
Both of these books use the complete annotated game format, with lots of prose and variations given only when they illuminate the game or an idea the author wants to illustrate in detail. In my opinion, this is the formula for a great opening book.
GM Gallagher uses many of his own games in his book, and it has a very personal feel to it. It's almost as though he is sitting down next to you as you read, showing you some great games, and what he thinks about them and the opening in general.
As for GM Uhlmann's book, it is filled with 60 complete annotated French games, and he plays black in every one of them! He is a premier GM and possibly one of the world's greatest French experts, and reading the book is a rare opportunity to "get inside the head" of a world class GM as he shares games and talks about his favorite opening.
I have never played the French, and have no plans to do so, but I felt like a book by a top-flight GM on his favorite opening, demonstrated as complete games, was too good a learning opportunity to pass up.
I have to give an "honorable mention" nod to the first edition of The King's Indian Attack by Ken Smith and John Hall, as I feel like they practically taught me how to play tournament chess 20 years ago, but that's more a personal recollection, and the books above are in a different and higher class.
Paul