Go back
Open vs. Closed games...

Open vs. Closed games...

Only Chess

B

Joined
20 Sep 04
Moves
79097
Clock
29 Jan 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

I've heard games referred to as 'Open' or 'Closed'. What is the definition of this? Is it cut-and-dried, or subjective?

Thanks in advance-

-Russell

M
me, not you

CaNaDa

Joined
25 Nov 04
Moves
46658
Clock
29 Jan 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

I think.. 1. e4 e5 are open games.. 1. d4 starts are closed games, and anything that starts 1. e4 and response is something else is a semi-open game.

Did I get that right? .. I'm sure if not I'll be corrected quickly.
The reasoning I believe is that in e4 e5 games, there is more movement, making the game more open.

pompomtom

Footscrazy

Joined
22 Aug 03
Moves
56559
Clock
29 Jan 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

As I understand it, a closed game is one where there is a locked, or at least crowded, pawn centre... the sort of game where knights are really handy for wiggling around the board, and bishops are frustrated. An open game, conversely, has space in the centre, so your long range pieces are at an advantage and can cover a lot of territory.

You can easily have either type from e4 or d4 openings.

P

Mumbai,India

Joined
09 Apr 03
Moves
2787
Clock
29 Jan 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Open or Close game is wrt center.
Game with one or many center pawns exchanged is open where as game with center pawns locked is closed.
In open games Bishop is prefered(over Knight) because of its long range, while in closed knight is prefered as it can jump over pieces.

Edit: Poms post is simul with the same message

MS

Under Cover

Joined
25 Feb 04
Moves
28912
Clock
29 Jan 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

All of the above answers are correct. The second post was correct in that openings beginning with 1. e4 e5 are classified as open games, even though they often end up as semi open or closed positions...so on and so forth with 1. d4 etc. Those are just generic classifications of OPENINGS groups. For a POSITION to be open or closed depends on the presence of center pawns, as noted in the third and fourth post. This is much more relevant than generic openings classifications, as it determines the strategies for each side in the game.

V
Caro-Kann Lover

Rishon-le-Zion

Joined
13 Dec 04
Moves
57234
Clock
29 Jan 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

There is smth newer classification :

A 1.e4 e5 - OPEN
B 1. e4 ... other than e5 - SEMI-OPEN
C. 1. d4 d5 - CLOSED
D. 1. d4 ... other than d5 - SEMI-CLOSED
E. 1. other than e4 or d4 - FLANKED

D

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
1983
Clock
29 Jan 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

From the Oxford Companion To Chess: Open Game=any game in which pawn exchanges open up files, diagonals, and ranks for use by the line pieces, as opposed to a Closed Game, in which the range of the pieces is restricted and they operate primarily behind the lines.

ketchuplover
Isolated Pawn

Wisconsin USA

Joined
09 Dec 01
Moves
71666
Clock
29 Jan 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Dodger11
From the Oxford Companion To Chess: Open Game=any game in which pawn exchanges open up files, diagonals, and ranks for use by the line pieces, as opposed to a Closed Game, in which the range of the pieces is restricted and they operate primarily behind the lines.
What subjects does this Oxford's book cover?

D

Joined
01 Oct 04
Moves
1983
Clock
29 Jan 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ketchuplover
What subjects does this Oxford's book cover?
It's a chess encyclopedia, it covers everything related to chess. It's a good reference book, I believe it's long out of print, but available on the net, if you want a used copy.

b

Hainesport, NJ, USA

Joined
22 Jun 04
Moves
17527
Clock
30 Jan 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

An open game is one in which you can move your elbows without knocking over pieces. A closed game is one in which you get a severe headache trying to calculate variations. A semi-closed (or semi-open game, if you will) is one in which you have dropped a couple of pawns for no compensation whatsoever and are trying to figure out how to slip out of the playing area inconspicuously. There, does that settle the issue?

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.