As an aside, digital clocks support "N moves in time T" time controls. For this, they count the moves based on how often the clock is pressed. So if your opponent doesn't press the clock, and then you move without pressing (because his time is running anyway), then the move counter will not get incremented.
Originally posted by VarenkaTrue, but your score sheet is the official record of your game, not the clock's move counter.
As an aside, digital clocks support "N moves in time T" time controls. For this, they count the moves based on how often the clock is pressed. So if your opponent doesn't press the clock, and then you move without pressing (because his time is running anyway), then the move counter will not get incremented.
Originally posted by Mad RookYou missed my point. For 40 moves in 2 hours, the players could both play their 40 moves on the board (and on their scoresheet) while the clock only knows about 39 moves. So it won't change to the next time allocation automatically.
True, but your score sheet is the official record of your game, not the clock's move counter.
So what happens if White has a long think of the actual 41st move? It's not going to come off the 2nd time control if the clock doesn't think the initial time control has been completed.
Originally posted by VarenkaI'm not sure what you're getting at, unless you mean that the players have the responsibility of staying on top of the correct number of moves in a non-sudden death time control and adjusting the clock's move counter accordingly. (Which I agree with.)
You missed my point. For 40 moves in 2 hours, the players could both play their 40 moves on the board (and on their scoresheet) while the clock only knows about 39 moves. So it won't change to the next time allocation automatically.
So what happens if White has a long think of the actual 41st move? It's not going to come off the 2nd time control if the clock doesn't think the initial time control has been completed.
Originally posted by Mad RookFor 40 moves in 2 hours, followed by all other moves in 1 hour, what if White takes just under 2 hours to complete 40 moves, followed by a 30 min think on move 41. You'd expect White to make the initial time control and the clock to show approx 30 mins for White's remaining time in the 2nd time control.
I'm not sure what you're getting at, unless you mean that the players have the responsibility of staying on top of the correct number of moves in a non-sudden death time control and adjusting the clock accordingly. (Which I agree with.)
But if the clock "misses a move", it will assume the 30 min think is part of the initial time control and not the 2nd. How and when does the error get remedied?
Originally posted by VarenkaI've never had this happen to me, but I think this is what should be done. When White's flag falls, this is a case of a premature flag fall (sometimes due to an incorrect setting, but in this case due to missing a move on the clock). If Black claims the time forfeit, White should dispute the claim, due to 40 moves having been reached on the scoresheet. The TD or arbiter should deny the time forfeit claim.
For 40 moves in 2 hours, followed by all other moves in 1 hour, what if White takes just under 2 hours to complete 40 moves, followed by a 30 min think on move 41. You'd expect White to make the initial time control and the clock to show approx 30 mins for White's remaining time in the 2nd time control.
But if the clock "misses a move", it will assume ...[text shortened]... part of the initial time control and not the 2nd. How and when does the error get remedied?
Edit - For the USCF rules this falls under Rule 16G (Premature Flag Fall)
Originally posted by Mad RookBut what if Black, having recorded 40 moves for both sides, realises there will be no flag claim.... decides to go for a stroll due to both players being given an extra hour... and then returns to see that's White's 2nd time control is not being decremented (while White continues to think)?
I've never had this happen to me, but I think this is what should be done. When White's flag falls, this is a case of a premature flag fall (sometimes due to an incorrect setting, but in this case due to missing a move on the clock). If Black claims the time forfeit, White should dispute the claim, due to 40 moves having been reached on the scoresheet. The ...[text shortened]... me forfeit claim.
Edit - For the USCF rules this falls under Rule 16G (Premature Flag Fall)
Then they have to get the TD and try to estimate the time that should be added to White's clock, etc. etc.
My initial point was to help avoid such confusion and hassle.
Originally posted by VarenkaThose are the kind of situations where you've glad that TDs exist. 🙂
But what if Black, having recorded 40 moves for both sides, realises there will be no flag claim.... decides to go for a stroll due to both players being given an extra hour... and then returns to see that's White's 2nd time control is not being decremented (while White continues to think)?
Then they have to get the TD and try to estimate the time that s ...[text shortened]... to White's clock, etc. etc.
My initial point was to help avoid such confusion and hassle.
I guess in that case, Black screwed up, and I guess the TD will have to resolve the issue. Probably the best way to avoid this kind of problem in a non-sudden death time control is for the players to correct the move counter before reaching the time control. That is, if your opponent fails to press his clock, and if you decide to let his time burn off, then after he realizes his mistake and starts to press his clock for the subsequent moves, then the players should correct the move counter before reaching the time control to avoid the scenario you described.