My point was that with weak players both white and black fail your test. Neither will know what to do with any advantage, nor will either know how to create one.
My case in point was the missed 1 move checkmate. You take the human chess player out of the equation in your evaluation.
2 edits
@Duchess64
This is what you said
In Eladar's cited game, it was irrelevant whether White 'missed 1 move checkmate' (sic) (what a clumsy expression).
White was hopelessly lost and would have been mated anyway.
----Are you going to answer my question about after white plays 4.Qf7#
How is this a lost position for white?