Go back
The opening move

The opening move

Only Chess

L

Joined
03 Feb 04
Moves
3332
Clock
27 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

In my opinion, the best all round opening move is e4, or as black e5 (assuming d4 or Nf3 was not played). What is everyone else's opinion?

P

Serbia

Joined
18 Oct 03
Moves
7211
Clock
27 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

"Best by test." -- Bobby Fischer (on 1.e4) 🙂

h

Joined
14 Oct 01
Moves
20676
Clock
27 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

No reason that e5 would be best for black...many would argue that c5 is better!

l

Joined
13 Feb 04
Moves
10148
Clock
27 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

I think that the best opening move is related to everyone'style... if you're an attacker, you'll chose e4 with white and you'll answer c5 with black, if you're a positional player c4 and Nf3 are better...
As a general rul (for the withe):
e4, d4, c4 and Nf3 are all ok
b3, f4, g3 are not so good but playable
all other moves are somewhat bad
and for the black, in reply to e4:
e5, c5, c6, e6, Nf6, d6, d5 and g6 are all good moves... you've just to know the main lines of the opening you choose!!!
Lord_ste

L

Joined
03 Feb 04
Moves
3332
Clock
27 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

I always play Nf6 as black as either the first or second move... mainly because I've played people who move 2. Qh5

s

Joined
08 Oct 03
Moves
19979
Clock
27 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Lenzar
I always play Nf6 as black as either the first or second move... mainly because I've played people who move 2. Qh5
2. Qh5 is a waste of a move.

After 1. e4 e5 2. Qh5 just play 2....Nc6

L

Joined
03 Feb 04
Moves
3332
Clock
27 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

1. e4 e5 2. Qh5 Nc6 3. Bc4 and then what? g6?

L

Amsterdam

Joined
26 Jan 03
Moves
27540
Clock
28 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lordste
I think that the best opening move is related to everyone'style... if you're an attacker, you'll chose e4 with white and you'll answer c5 with black, if you're a positional player c4 and Nf3 are better...
As a general rul (for the withe):
e4, d4, c4 and Nf3 are all ok
b3, f4, g3 are not so good but playable
all other moves are somewhat bad
and for ...[text shortened]... re all good moves... you've just to know the main lines of the opening you choose!!!
Lord_ste
Ever played 1.f4? (It's a question, not a questionable move, it's a great move!)
I don't know if you're a GM, but I doubt it that you'll beat me when I play it! :-)

Olav

l
Into the Breach!

San Francisco

Joined
24 Feb 03
Moves
3420
Clock
28 Feb 04
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Panuka
"Best by test." -- Bobby Fischer (on 1.e4) 🙂
Notice he switched to d4 when the chips were down against Spassky...

But your question contains the germ of another question - why play chess? Do you want to play positions that have been played hundreds of times before before? Do you still want to be in the books at move 17? Do you want to walk the same paths as club players all over the world?

[sound of inspirational music]

After joining the RED HOT PAWN STARS I discovered that chess isn't just about the nuances of the Nimzo-Indian, the paths of the Petroff, the twists of the Trompowsky... No!

[music louder]

It can be about experimentation - playing a position that has never been seen before on a chessboard! It can be about playing a sound opening that is so untested many of the critical positions have never appeared in tournament play! (See Simon Williams' book on the Classical Dutch.) It can, in short, be an adventure, in which books and theory have no standing and winning and losing take second place to the joy of discovery!

Which is also probably why my rating sucks.😉

s

Joined
08 Oct 03
Moves
19979
Clock
28 Feb 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Lenzar
1. e4 e5 2. Qh5 Nc6 3. Bc4 and then what? g6?
1. e4 e5 2. Qh5 Nc6 3. Bc4 g6 4. Qf3 f6 - and white has lost a tempo.

p
High Priest

The Volcano

Joined
19 Nov 03
Moves
24342
Clock
28 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

But your question contains the germ of another question - why play chess? Do you want to play positions that have been played hundreds of times before before? Do you still want to be in the books at move 17? Do you want to walk the same paths as club players all over the world?

[sound of inspirational music]

After joining the RED HOT PAWN STARS I discovered that chess isn't just about th ...[text shortened]... g take second place to the joy of discovery!

Which is also probably why my rating sucks.😉
[/b]
[and the crowd goes wild!] HORRAY!

I love unconventional, or just ill-liked openings. Right now, I'm engaged in a project with Der Bringer to find a line of the King's Gambit that doesn't get white into immediate tactical trouble with best play from black... haven't found one yet, but if anyone else is interested in this little project, I'll e-mail 'em the pgn files of Bringer kicking my ass :-)

h

e2

Joined
29 Jun 03
Moves
3535
Clock
28 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by sylvander
1. e4 e5 2. Qh5 Nc6 3. Bc4 g6 4. Qf3 f6 - and white has lost a tempo.
I would prefer 4...Nf6 myself.

h

e2

Joined
29 Jun 03
Moves
3535
Clock
28 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lloydk
Notice he switched to d4 when the chips were down against Spassky...
Probably only to avoid Spassky team preparation, not because he considered 1.d4 stronger. Notice he also went the whole '72 match without playing his trusty KID!

L

Joined
03 Feb 04
Moves
3332
Clock
28 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by huntingbear
I would prefer 4...Nf6 myself.
I tend to agree.. leaves more pawns defending the king when O-O is played later on.

h

e2

Joined
29 Jun 03
Moves
3535
Clock
28 Feb 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Lenzar
I tend to agree.. leaves more pawns defending the king when O-O is played later on.
Too true! And ...Bg7 is natural after 3...g6, but not after 4...f6. Also, 4...Nf6 develops a piece to its best square, while 4...f6 just spends a tempo and creates weaknesses.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.