Was this really drawn?

dmnelson84

Only Chess

31 Dec 06

dmnelson84

Joined: 27 Oct 05
Moves: 72627

31 Dec 06

Game 2952973

I offered the draw and he accepted. I think he could have possibly won. Anyone agree?

dmnelson84

Joined: 27 Oct 05
Moves: 72627

31 Dec 06

To elaborate, had he brought his king to the middle of the board and then exchanged pawns, he could have penetrated with his king afterwards. No?

techsouth

Garner, NC

Joined: 04 Nov 05
Moves: 31225

31 Dec 06

Originally posted by dmnelson84
To elaborate, had he brought his king to the middle of the board and then exchanged pawns, he could have penetrated with his king afterwards. No?

I think this is a draw.

Of course you could find a way to lose it if you were trying, but I think you can hold the position if you want. Also, he can hold the position if prevent you from winning.

If he advances his pawn on column d, you could just sit back and wait, making him take one of your pawns. Then when you recapture, his King still cannot break through. If you did not sit back and way, you can still capture the pawn, but that gives you a passed pawn that he has to deal with. I don't know where that will lead, but I think he would be hesitant to give you that opportunity.

All you need to do is move your king back and forth and he can't break through. Likewise, if he keeps his king near, you can't move your knight at all. If you offer him a trade by moving to g1, I think he benefits from the trade and might make something of his two passed pawns now that he can press forward with his king. I haven't looked carefully at that, but I would probably take a draw from either side of the board in this game.

Dies Irae

I Love U

LaLa Land

Joined: 06 Dec 06
Moves: 4631

31 Dec 06

It looks like a draw. Either of you could have ruined your positions if you wanted to, but as it stands, it looks like a draw to me.

dmnelson84

Joined: 27 Oct 05
Moves: 72627

31 Dec 06

1 edit

Thanks for the responses.

~~Von Bardeleben~~

Joined: 15 Dec 06
Moves: 1588

31 Dec 06

black is winning, but it's hard to convert to a win

wargamer66

Steve B.

Salt Lake City

Joined: 08 Sep 06
Moves: 38353

31 Dec 06

Draw, as long as you keep his king from penetrating at f4 and g4. Black isn't winning here.

hakaman

Joined: 05 Jun 06
Moves: 1772

02 Jan 07

Originally posted by dmnelson84
Game 2952973

I offered the draw and he accepted. I think he could have possibly won. Anyone agree?

you were the only 1 that could have altered the game reason being all your pieces were on white and he had a black bishop where you had a knight

hakaman

Joined: 05 Jun 06
Moves: 1772

02 Jan 07

Originally posted by dmnelson84
Game 2952973

I offered the draw and he accepted. I think he could have possibly won. Anyone agree?

but yes a draw

Mctayto

Highlander

Planet Earth

Joined: 10 Dec 04
Moves: 1044629

02 Jan 07

Originally posted by dmnelson84
Game 2952973

I offered the draw and he accepted. I think he could have possibly won. Anyone agree?

To all this debate it was also 4.am 🙂
I figured that other than falling on ones sword it was a draw as both parties needed his opponent to help him win 🙂

dmnelson84

Joined: 27 Oct 05
Moves: 72627

02 Jan 07

Hey Mctatyto, thanks for the late night chess. It was a pleasure.

Mctayto

Highlander

Planet Earth

Joined: 10 Dec 04
Moves: 1044629

03 Jan 07

Originally posted by dmnelson84
Hey Mctatyto, thanks for the late night chess. It was a pleasure.

Most enjoyable 🙂
Next time I will have match sticks to hold my eyes open 🙂