1. In Christ
    Joined
    30 Apr '07
    Moves
    172
    04 Jun '07 16:59
    A man walks up to you and says, "I am lying." Is his statement true or false?
  2. Joined
    31 May '07
    Moves
    696
    04 Jun '07 18:14
    It is false. He is saying it with the intention to create a paradox, not with the intention to insincerely deceive, and thus, is not lying. He is also not telling the truth, but that isn't relevant. The point is that he is not lying.
  3. Standard memberPBE6
    Bananarama
    False berry
    Joined
    14 Feb '04
    Moves
    28719
    04 Jun '07 18:23
    Originally posted by doodinthemood
    It is false. He is saying it with the intention to create a paradox, not with the intention to insincerely deceive, and thus, is not lying. He is also not telling the truth, but that isn't relevant. The point is that he is not lying.
    I believe what the original poster was driving at was that the statement "I am lying" is undecidable. However, given Godel's original statement:

    "For any consistent formal, computably enumerable theory that proves basic arithmetical truths, an arithmetical statement that is true but not provable in the theory can be constructed. That is, any effectively generated theory capable of expressing elementary arithmetic cannot be both consistent and complete." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del%27s_incompleteness_theorems)

    I'm not sure the English language and it's grammar constitute are consistent, formal, or computably enumerable enough to use this terminology.
  4. Standard memberagryson
    AGW Hitman
    http://xkcd.com/386/
    Joined
    23 Feb '07
    Moves
    7113
    04 Jun '07 18:41
    It depends, is he the type of guy who wants to make a good first impression?
  5. Joined
    11 Nov '05
    Moves
    43938
    04 Jun '07 19:18
    Originally posted by Jirakon
    A man walks up to you and says, "I am lying." Is his statement true or false?
    Statement P = {A man walks up to you and says, "I am lying."}
    Is P true or false?

    Well, I had my brother to walk up to me and say it word by word (I had to bribe him with a fiver first) so now I'm sure it is true.
  6. Standard memberagryson
    AGW Hitman
    http://xkcd.com/386/
    Joined
    23 Feb '07
    Moves
    7113
    04 Jun '07 19:21
    but it says is _his_ statement true or false.
  7. Joined
    31 May '07
    Moves
    696
    04 Jun '07 19:35
    Originally posted by agryson
    but it says is _his_ statement true or false.
    and it is false, as he is not aiming to deceive. The paradox attempted at fails as it doesn't recognise you can not tell the truh and not lie at the same time.
  8. Standard memberagryson
    AGW Hitman
    http://xkcd.com/386/
    Joined
    23 Feb '07
    Moves
    7113
    04 Jun '07 19:42
    ? I dunno...
  9. Joined
    11 Nov '05
    Moves
    43938
    04 Jun '07 21:05
    Originally posted by agryson
    but it says is _his_ statement true or false.
    I read _this_! Are you sure he didn't spelled it wrong?
  10. Standard memberagryson
    AGW Hitman
    http://xkcd.com/386/
    Joined
    23 Feb '07
    Moves
    7113
    04 Jun '07 21:13
    I dunno, let's ask him... Jirakon?
  11. In Christ
    Joined
    30 Apr '07
    Moves
    172
    04 Jun '07 21:51
    "his statement" refers to the statement made by the man, namely, "I am lying." His statement does not include the initial "a man walks up to you and says," as he did not say that.

    He is saying it with the intention to create a paradox, not with the intention to insincerely deceive

    How do you know what his intentions are? What if he is insane, believes he is telling the truth, and insincerely tries to deceive you? Then it would be a true statement.

    There is enough information given to either prove that no matter what the man's intentions, the statement itself must be true, or that no matter what the man's intentions, the statement itself must be false. I suppose that could be a big hint 🙂
  12. Standard memberagryson
    AGW Hitman
    http://xkcd.com/386/
    Joined
    23 Feb '07
    Moves
    7113
    04 Jun '07 21:52
    It's false, because if he walked up to you he can't by lying down, he must be standing.
  13. In Christ
    Joined
    30 Apr '07
    Moves
    172
    04 Jun '07 22:13
    Got it! Good job, angryson.
  14. Standard memberagryson
    AGW Hitman
    http://xkcd.com/386/
    Joined
    23 Feb '07
    Moves
    7113
    04 Jun '07 22:30
    Yay!
    Alex:1
    Everyone else:lots
  15. Solaris
    Joined
    09 Jul '06
    Moves
    2810
    07 Jun '07 22:41
    Originally posted by Jirakon
    A man walks up to you and says, "I am lying." Is his statement true or false?
    it is impossible to tell. There is no axiom to verify the statement.
Back to Top