# A trip to Asia

DumDum81
Posers and Puzzles 15 Mar '04 20:57
1. 15 Mar '04 20:57
A man was on a treck across Asia. Along the way he was caught by robbers. Thay ordered them to make a statement about himself. If he told a trouth he would be hanged, but if he told a lie they would shoot him. After a few min. of thought he uttered something that confussed the robbers so much that they let him go. What did he say? If you can't getit messege me.
2. TheMaster37
Kupikupopo!
16 Mar '04 07:43
Originally posted by DumDum81
A man was on a treck across Asia. Along the way he was caught by robbers. Thay ordered them to make a statement about himself. If he told a trouth he would be hanged, but if he told a lie they would shoot him. After a few min. of thought he uttered something that confussed the robbers so much that they let him go. What did he say? If you can't getit messege me.
&quot;What i am saying now isn't true&quot;
3. 16 Mar '04 22:573 edits
Originally posted by DumDum81
A man was on a trek across Asia. Along the way he was caught by robbers. Thay ordered him to make a statement about himself. If he told a truth he would be hanged, but if he told a lie they would shoot him. After he spoke, they let him go. What did he say? If you can't get it messege me.
he says, &quot;i will be killed by bullets [or by being shot]&quot;.
the robbers are thus faced with a paradox:
if they take his statement as true, then they hang him and the statement has been rendered false. if they take the statement as a lie, then they shoot him, making the statement true!
the robbers thus have no choice but to release the wily trekker.
4. 18 Mar '04 20:30
You got the answer BarefootChessPlayer! (they could have hung him to half dead though)ðŸ™„
5. TheMaster37
Kupikupopo!
21 Mar '04 14:25
What about my answer? It is a statement about what he's saying, and thus about himself. Also, the robbers can't determine whether the statement is true or false, since that statement is a paradox.
6. 23 Mar '04 13:522 edits
Originally posted by BarefootChessPlayer
he says, "[b]i will be killed by bullets [or by being shot]".
the robbers are thus faced with a paradox:
if they take his statement as true, then they hang him and the statement has been rendered false. if they ta ...[text shortened]...
the robbers thus have no choice but to release the wily trekker.[/b]
Clearly sensible bandits would then balance the man on a chair - set up the noose round his neck, and then shoot at the chair legs until it collapsed. It's somewhat safer for him to state &quot;I won't be killed by hanging&quot;.
7. 23 Mar '04 17:051 edit
Originally posted by DumDum81
A man was on a treck across Asia. Along the way he was caught by robbers. Thay ordered them to make a statement about himself. If he told a trouth he would be hanged, but if he told a lie they would shoot him. After a few min. of thoug ...[text shortened]... ey let him go. What did he say? If you can't getit messege me.
Or he could say - &quot;My sister's name is Joanne&quot;. Seeing as the robbers would have no way of verifyiing / disproving this statement they would again have to let him go. Or would they? Most robbers would decide the man had either lied or told the truth and would hang him AND shoot him - since they never stated they wouldn't do both.
8. 23 Mar '04 20:30
They would take his word for it
9. 24 Mar '04 01:41
Originally posted by iamatiger
Clearly sensible bandits would then balance the man on a chair - set up the noose round his neck, and then shoot at the chair legs until it collapsed. It's somewhat safer for him to state "I won't be killed by hanging".
i like that!
frankly, if i found myself in such a predicament, i'd be unlikely to come up with a suitable statement.
here is a slightly different concept:
in logic, a statement is any assertion that is either true or false.
what is the shortest english assertion that is not a statement?
(imperative sentences such as &quot;go&quot; and vague answers to specific questions such as 'i am[ not]&quot;, &quot;i do[ not]&quot;, and &quot;i will[ not]&quot; are not assertions.)
10. 24 Mar '04 16:11
Originally posted by BarefootChessPlayer
i like that!
frankly, if i found myself in such a predicament, i'd be unlikely to come up with a suitable statement.
here is a slightly different concept:
in logic, a statement is any assertion that is either true or false.
what is the shortest english assertion that is not a statement?
(imperative sentences such as "go" and ...[text shortened]... ific questions such as 'i am[ not]", "i do[ not]", and "i will[ not]" are not assertions.)
Hmm, I don't really know what qualifies as a statement but I'll have a go anyway...

&quot;This isn't a statement&quot;?
11. 24 Mar '04 20:54
Originally posted by iamatiger
Hmm, I don't really know what qualifies as a statement but I'll have a go anyway...
"This isn't a statement"?
i would classify that as a false assertion and therefore a statement.
in order for an assertion not to be a statement, it would have to be both true and false simultaneously, be neither (which is usually not an assertion at all), or be a paradox whose truth or falsity is indeterminate.
12. 24 Mar '04 21:35
In communication a statement is considered false if it contains a paradox, for example:

the sentence below is false
the sentence above is true.

would be false as it is a paradox.
13. 24 Mar '04 21:58
Originally posted by iamatiger
Hmm, I don't really know what qualifies as a statement but I'll have a go anyway...

"This isn't a statement"?
Ok - you're right, obviously false that one ðŸ™‚

&quot;This sentence is false.&quot;?
14. 24 Mar '04 23:49
Originally posted by iamatiger
Ok - you're right, obviously false that one ðŸ™‚