Originally posted by talzamir
It reveals the hidden premises for sure. ^_^
Gamemaster: #1, you've had a minute to ponder. Any idea what you wear?
Contestant #1: no clue, I see nothing and no one has spoken.
Gamemaster: #2, you've had two minutes. What color?
Contestant #2: dunno
Gamemaster: #3, three minutes in, what do you wear?
Contestant #3: I don't have enough informatio ...[text shortened]... waiting for me to make a total idiot of myself.. dunno.
Contestant #3: *snickers* gotcha
I think it is flawed:
3 refuses to say anything even though he can see two whites.
2 Can see a white, since 3 says nothing, 2 says "my hat must be blue"
It is announced that 2 is wrong.
1 thinks, "For 2 to announce that he must have been sure, therefore he must think 3 is not answering because he can't see two whites, however if I was wearing blue then 2 would not have know what to say, therefore I must be wearing white.
1 quickly says white and 3 loses the game.