Go back
Dimensional twists

Dimensional twists

Posers and Puzzles

k

Joined
24 Nov 05
Moves
1113
Clock
29 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

how is it possible to have a one-sided strip of paper? how about a one sided 3D object?

B
Non-Subscriber

RHP IQ

Joined
17 Mar 05
Moves
1345
Clock
29 Dec 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ketch90
how about a one sided 3D object?
A solid sphere.

M

Joined
12 Mar 03
Moves
44411
Clock
29 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

A one-sided strip of paper (Möbius ring) is a 3D object.

B
Non-Subscriber

RHP IQ

Joined
17 Mar 05
Moves
1345
Clock
29 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Mephisto2
A one-sided strip of paper (Möbius ring) is a 3D object.
Are you sure?

TP
Leak-Proof

under the sink

Joined
08 Aug 04
Moves
12493
Clock
29 Dec 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

A Möbius ring actually has two sides because the paper has thickness.

Envision a flexible rectangular solid with dimensions of, say, 1 x 1 x 8. If you can join the two square ends together but incorporate a quarter twist in so doing, then you will have a 3D solid object with adjacent edges that are 90 degrees offset from each other and still only has one surface.

k

Joined
24 Nov 05
Moves
1113
Clock
29 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

is it possible to make a bottle one-sided?

i

Joined
30 Oct 04
Moves
7813
Clock
29 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Well there is the Klein bottle. Not exactly a bottle though...

M

Joined
12 Mar 03
Moves
44411
Clock
29 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Bowmann
Are you sure?
Approximatively. I assumed a "strip" to be of 2D nature (lenght, width and no/extremely small depth) and you need a 3d dimension to give it a twist to make a Möbius ring.

Si no e vero, e bien trovato.

k

Joined
24 Nov 05
Moves
1113
Clock
29 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

no habla espanol

TP
Leak-Proof

under the sink

Joined
08 Aug 04
Moves
12493
Clock
30 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ketch90
is it possible to make a bottle one-sided?
is a doughnut one-sided?

B
Non-Subscriber

RHP IQ

Joined
17 Mar 05
Moves
1345
Clock
30 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by The Plumber
is a doughnut one-sided?
Not Nessie celery.

r

Joined
15 Mar 05
Moves
3095
Clock
30 Dec 05
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ketch90
how is it possible to have a one-sided strip of paper? how about a one sided 3D object?
If you are looking for the 3D equivalent of the mobius strip, it is called a Klein Bottle. A true Klein bottle is actually 4 dimensional, but we (humans) make 3D projections of true Klein Bottles, and the inside does turn out to be the outside.

T
Kupikupopo!

Out of my mind

Joined
25 Oct 02
Moves
20443
Clock
31 Dec 05
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rheymans
If you are looking for the 3D equivalent of the mobius strip, it is called a Klein Bottle. A true Klein bottle is actually 4 dimensional, but we (humans) make 3D projections of true Klein Bottles, and the inside does turn out to be the outside.
Would you care to elaborate on that?

The mobius strip is still 2 dimensional btw...a cilindric shell is also 2 dimensional.

There is a formula so calculate the dimension of an object:

D = log(f)/log(2)

D is the dimension, f is the factor. The factor is how many times the object increases in size when the length/withs/depth/.. are doubled.

A cube thus has factor 8 and has dimension D=log(8)/log(2)=3

A mobius strip becomes 4 times as large and thus has dimension D=log(4)/log(2)=2

The Bottle has dimension 3.

r

Joined
15 Mar 05
Moves
3095
Clock
01 Jan 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by TheMaster37
Would you care to elaborate on that?

The mobius strip is still 2 dimensional btw...a cilindric shell is also 2 dimensional.

There is a formula so calculate the dimension of an object:

D = log(f)/log(2)

D is the dimension, f is the factor. The factor is how many times the object increases in size when the length/withs/depth/.. are doubled.

...[text shortened]... becomes 4 times as large and thus has dimension D=log(4)/log(2)=2

The Bottle has dimension 3.
I am not familiar with the formula you have given for calculating dimensions. This link explains the Klein bottle better than I can.

http://www.kleinbottle.com/whats_a_klein_bottle.htm

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.