1. Standard memberorfeo
    Paralysed analyst
    On a ship of fools
    Joined
    26 May '04
    Moves
    25780
    28 Jun '05 22:14
    Did he think the train was on fire?
  2. The Lowlands
    Joined
    12 Nov '04
    Moves
    1894
    28 Jun '05 23:19
    Originally posted by orfeo
    Did he think the train was on fire?
    NOPE.
  3. Joined
    24 May '05
    Moves
    1958
    29 Jun '05 11:031 edit
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with the train?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with anything else?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with himself?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with anybody else?
    Did he believed that if he didn't kill himself he would have died another way?
    Did he believed that someone wanted to kill him

    Is anything what happened before is relevant?
    Did he want to smoke in the train?

    the place of the train is relevant...
    Is the country where the train is relevant?
    Is the distance from the train to the men's destination relevant?
    Is the distance from the train to the next train station relevant?
  4. Standard memberAThousandYoung
    or different places
    tinyurl.com/2tp8tyx8
    Joined
    23 Aug '04
    Moves
    26660
    29 Jun '05 11:111 edit
    Is there a play on words involved in the original presentation of the puzzle?

    Did this actually happen in reality?

    This was unclear:

    Could anyone else be it? (is it a specific person) NO

    If the NO applied to the first question, it means the opposite as if NO applied to the second question, I think. So, to clarify:

    Is the man a specific man?
    Does the answer include knowing the man's name?
  5. The Lowlands
    Joined
    12 Nov '04
    Moves
    1894
    29 Jun '05 13:49
    Is there a play on words involved in the original presentation of the puzzle? NO.

    Did this actually happen in reality? NO. (Not that I know off/ highly unlikely.)

    Is the man a specific man? NO/YES: he's not famous or anything but it could not have happened to just anybody.

    Does the answer include knowing the man's name? NO.
  6. Joined
    30 Dec '04
    Moves
    163886
    30 Jun '05 00:461 edit
    Did he meet someone in the smoking section?
    Did he have a medical condition?
  7. Standard memberPalynka
    Upward Spiral
    Halfway
    Joined
    02 Aug '04
    Moves
    8702
    30 Jun '05 01:04
    Did he try to smoke?
    Did he try to smoke somewhere where he wouldn't be seen?
    Did he try to smoke in the dark?
    Did the fact he needed to smoke made him commit suicide?
  8. The Lowlands
    Joined
    12 Nov '04
    Moves
    1894
    30 Jun '05 03:34
    Did he meet someone in the smoking section? NO
    Did he have a medical condition? YES


  9. The Lowlands
    Joined
    12 Nov '04
    Moves
    1894
    30 Jun '05 03:351 edit
    Did he try to smoke? NO
    Did he try to smoke somewhere where he wouldn't be seen? NO
    Did he try to smoke in the dark? NO
    Did the fact he needed to smoke made him commit suicide? NO

  10. Joined
    24 May '05
    Moves
    1958
    30 Jun '05 12:20
    Originally posted by Florrat
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with the train?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with anything else?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with himself?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with anybody else?
    Did he believed that if he didn't kill himself he would have died another way?
    Did he believed that s ...[text shortened]... men's destination relevant?
    Is the distance from the train to the next train station relevant?
    Could you please answer my questions, maybe you didn't saw them...:

    Did he believed that something (has) happened with the train?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with anything else?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with himself?
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with anybody else?
    Did he believed that if he didn't kill himself he would have died another way?
    Did he believed that someone wanted to kill him

    Is anything what happened before is relevant?
    Did he want to smoke in the train?

    the place of the train is relevant...
    Is the country where the train is relevant?
    Is the distance from the train to the men's destination relevant?
    Is the distance from the train to the next train station relevant?
  11. The Lowlands
    Joined
    12 Nov '04
    Moves
    1894
    30 Jun '05 12:52
    Could you please answer my questions, maybe you didn't saw them...: SORRY ABOUT THAT!

    Did he believed that something (has) happened with the train? NO
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with anything else? NO
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with himself? YES
    Did he believed that something (has) happened with anybody else? NO
    Did he believed that if he didn't kill himself he would have died another way? NO
    Did he believed that someone wanted to kill him NO

    Is anything what happened before is relevant? YES
    Did he want to smoke in the train? NO

    the place of the train is relevant...
    Is the country where the train is relevant? NO
    Is the distance from the train to the men's destination relevant? YES, the distance from point A (where he got in) to B (where he was going) is relevant.
    Is the distance from the train to the next train station relevant? NO
  12. Standard memberPalynka
    Upward Spiral
    Halfway
    Joined
    02 Aug '04
    Moves
    8702
    30 Jun '05 15:14
    Did anyone else die?
    Did anyone else get injured?
    Where they in a tunnel?
    Did the man die the way he was planning?
    Did he have breathing problems?
    Did he have a heart condition?
  13. The Lowlands
    Joined
    12 Nov '04
    Moves
    1894
    30 Jun '05 15:32
    Did anyone else die? NO
    Did anyone else get injured? NO
    Where they in a tunnel? YES
    Did the man die the way he was planning? YES
    Did he have breathing problems? NO
    Did he have a heart condition? NO

  14. Standard memberPalynka
    Upward Spiral
    Halfway
    Joined
    02 Aug '04
    Moves
    8702
    30 Jun '05 18:51
    Were the lights on during the whole trip?
    Did he do something when it was completely dark?

    Did he die because nobody had a lighter?
    Did he die because nobody had a match?
    Did he die because nobody had cigarretes?
    Did he die because nobody had cigars?
    Did he die because they had no way of producing smoke?
    Did he die because they had no way of producing fire?
  15. The Lowlands
    Joined
    12 Nov '04
    Moves
    1894
    30 Jun '05 18:56
    Were the lights on during the whole trip? NO
    Did he do something when it was completely dark? YES

    Did he die because nobody had a lighter? NO
    Did he die because nobody had a match? NO
    Did he die because nobody had cigarretes? NO
    Did he die because nobody had cigars? NO
    Did he die because they had no way of producing smoke? NO
    Did he die because they had no way of producing fire? NO
Back to Top

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.I Agree