Posers and Puzzles

Posers and Puzzles

  1. Standard memberwolfgang59
    Mr. Wolf
    at home
    Joined
    09 Jun '07
    Moves
    46124
    03 Mar '14 21:54
    I posted a similar problem on here a couple of years ago, if you
    remember that don't contribute, just sit back and enjoy the discussions!

    I phone a work colleague up and his daughter answers the phone. He has
    previously told me that he has two children at home, I had no idea he had
    a daughter. What are the chances that the other child is also a girl?
  2. Subscriberjoe shmo
    Strange Egg
    podunk, PA
    Joined
    10 Dec '06
    Moves
    7733
    03 Mar '14 23:58
    Originally posted by wolfgang59
    I posted a similar problem on here a couple of years ago, if you
    remember that don't contribute, just sit back and enjoy the discussions!

    I phone a work colleague up and his daughter answers the phone. He has
    previously told me that he has two children at home, I had no idea he had
    a daughter. What are the chances that the other child is also a girl?
    I'm going to stick my neck out here and say the probability is 1/3?
  3. Standard membertalzamir
    Art, not a Toil
    60.13N / 25.01E
    Joined
    19 Sep '11
    Moves
    46223
    04 Mar '14 14:20
    Agreed =)
  4. SubscriberPonderable
    chemist
    Linkenheim
    Joined
    22 Apr '05
    Moves
    531554
    04 Mar '14 14:29
    Well the items are (elder sibling/younger sibling):

    b/b (evidently untrue)
    g/b
    b/g
    g/g

    so 1 in three should be correct.
  5. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16172
    04 Mar '14 16:002 edits
    b/b (b1 answers) nope
    b/b (b2 answers) nope
    b/g (b answers) nope
    b/g (g answers)
    g/b (g answers)
    g/b (b answers) nope
    g/g (g1 answers)
    g/g (g2 answers)

    I'm going to say 1/2

    Why would it be any different than:
    "I flip a coin, and it comes up heads, what are the chances that my next flip is heads?"

    You could use the same logic that you guys just used if you had already flipped the coins and were asking after the fact.
  6. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16172
    04 Mar '14 16:06
    Note that this is different than the problem:

    I have four socks, two black and two blue. I randomly put to of the socks in a bag.

    You grab one sock out of the bag, and it is black. What is the probability that the other sock is black?
  7. Subscriberjoe shmo
    Strange Egg
    podunk, PA
    Joined
    10 Dec '06
    Moves
    7733
    04 Mar '14 22:19
    So... before the phone call the probability that both of the children were girls was 1/4.

    After the phone call the probability that both of the children are girls is 1/3 and the probability the the other child is a girl is 1/2.

    Is this a correct line of reasoning, or not?
  8. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16172
    05 Mar '14 00:001 edit
    Originally posted by joe shmo
    So... before the phone call the probability that both of the children were girls was 1/4.

    After the phone call the probability that both of the children are girls is 1/3 and the probability the the other child is a girl is 1/2.

    Is this a correct line of reasoning, or not?
    You know the first child is a girl.

    If the other child is a girl, then they're both girls. How could the probabilities be different?
  9. Shanghai
    Joined
    16 Feb '06
    Moves
    115340
    05 Mar '14 08:17
    I know that if this person has two children, one of the a girl called sue then the probability the other one is a girl is 1/3.

    If a person has two children, the oldest one is a girl called sue then the probability is now 1/2.

    I would go with the BB, BG, GB, GG explanation and go with 1/3 however often the oldest child is the one who answers the phone.
  10. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16172
    05 Mar '14 15:25
    Let's take an infinite set of families with two children, where children have an equal probability of being boys or girls, and you ask the question:

    "Of all of the families with at least one girl, what is the probability that both children in that family are girls?"

    Then the answer is 1/3

    If, on the other hand, you randomly choose one family, and then randomly sample one of the children, and discover that child is a girl, then the probability that the other child is a girl is not conditionally related to your sample and the probability is 1/2.
  11. Standard memberwolfgang59
    Mr. Wolf
    at home
    Joined
    09 Jun '07
    Moves
    46124
    05 Mar '14 19:46
    KEEP GOING GUYS 😀
  12. Shanghai
    Joined
    16 Feb '06
    Moves
    115340
    06 Mar '14 02:22
    Of course if you phone the work colleague up somewhere that is not his home it could be one of his 5 children that have left home.

    If you have four two children families BB, BG, GB, GG. You take a random sample of one by for instance phone. There is only one case in which the other child matches your sample (and one case which is clearly excluded by the result of the sample). So I am still sticking with 1/3.
  13. Standard memberwolfgang59
    Mr. Wolf
    at home
    Joined
    09 Jun '07
    Moves
    46124
    06 Mar '14 02:39
    Originally posted by deriver69
    Of course if you phone the work colleague up somewhere that is not his home it could be one of his 5 children that have left home.

    If you have four two children families BB, BG, GB, GG. You take a random sample of one by for instance phone. There is only one case in which the other child matches your sample (and one case which is clearly excluded by the result of the sample). So I am still sticking with 1/3.
    1/3 is incorrect. Think again.

    In fact it may help to consider the same problem ... but with gender reversed!
  14. Standard membertalzamir
    Art, not a Toil
    60.13N / 25.01E
    Joined
    19 Sep '11
    Moves
    46223
    06 Mar '14 12:17
    I thought again.. yep. 50%
  15. Standard membersmw6869
    Granny
    Parts Unknown
    Joined
    19 Jan '07
    Moves
    73106
    06 Mar '14 21:07
    50/52


    GRANNY.
Back to Top