Originally posted by iamatiger
Yeah - realised that just after the option to edit the message expired 🙂 The second challenge where you don't know whether fools gold is light or heavy still stands though 🙂 The current best guess of 7 can be beaten significantly!
Let me try. Number the balls 1 to 8.
l: means the balance goes to the left
r: the balance goes to the right
=: the balance stays horizontal
1H means ball 1 is heavier
1L means ball 1 is lighter
Round 1: 1 2 3 vs 4 5 6
a) if l: then round 2: 1 4 vs 2 5
a1) if l: then round 3: 1 vs 7
if l: then 1H
if =: then 5L
a2) if =: then round 3: 3 vs 7
if l: then 3H
if =: then 6L
a3) if r: then round 3: 2 vs 7
if l: then 2H
if =: then 4L
b) if =: then round 2: 1 vs 7
b1) if l: then 7L
b2) if r: then 7H
b3) if = then round 3: 1 vs 8
if l: then 8L
if r: then 8H
c) if r: then round 2: 1 4 vs 2 5
c1) if l: then round 3: 4 vs 7
if l: then 4H
if =: then 2L
c2) if =: then round 3: 3 vs 7
if =: then 6H
if r: then 3L
c3) if r: then round 3: 5 vs 7
if l: then 5H
if =: then 1L
I hope I didn't mess up. Allways 3 actions, except in one case where 2 suffice.