Go back
Greatest Problem Ever! (You can't do it)

Greatest Problem Ever! (You can't do it)

Posers and Puzzles

C
Standard memberCodfish

On the computer

Joined
30 Mar 06
Moves
675
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

How many non-intersecting chords of length N can fit into a circle of radius R?

P.S. If you don't know what this means, don't even try.
P.P.S. Show your work or you'll get no credit

C
Standard memberCodfish

On the computer

Joined
30 Mar 06
Moves
675
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

P.P.P.S: This really isn't that great, I just wanted to grab your attention.
P.P.P.P.S. This came to me in a flash of inspiration

f
Standard memberfierytorment
Mr. Flame of Fury

Winona Lake

Joined
09 Feb 05
Moves
29318
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

who care? 😉

L
Standard memberLemonJello

Joined
24 Apr 05
Moves
3061
Clock
19 Apr 06
2 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Codfish
How many non-intersecting chords of length N can fit into a circle of radius R?

P.S. If you don't know what this means, don't even try.
P.P.S. Show your work or you'll get no credit
At first glance I would say the answer is the following:

1, if N = 2R.

The nearest whole number that is less than or equal to Pi/[InverseSine(N/2R)], if N < 2R.

Is this what you got?

Edit: To get the above answer, I am simply dividing 2*Pi by the angle ACB, where A and B are the terminal points of some chord of length N, and C is the center of the circle.

C
Standard memberChessJester

EDMONTON ALBERTA

Joined
30 Sep 05
Moves
10841
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

INFINITE!! 😀

C
Standard memberCodfish

On the computer

Joined
30 Mar 06
Moves
675
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Hint: If the circle is a unit circle, then you can fit 2chords between N=2 and N=Sqrrt3, and 3 chords between sqrtt3 and sqrrt2.

L
Standard memberLemonJello

Joined
24 Apr 05
Moves
3061
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Codfish
Hint: If the circle is a unit circle, then you can fit 2chords between N=2 and N=Sqrrt3, and 3 chords between sqrtt3 and sqrrt2.
That is consistent with the answer I already gave.

C
Standard memberCodfish

On the computer

Joined
30 Mar 06
Moves
675
Clock
19 Apr 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Sorry lemon Jello, I missed your post. (Somehow😳)
That is indeed what I got. Please note, though, that the maximum side length for each maximum #of chords is .................................................................
Never mind, its too obvious for me to say it out loud without being blinded
:'(

l
Standard memberlaur3tta

Joined
12 Apr 06
Moves
202
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

it would be infinite, as your chords could be infinitely thin.

C
Standard memberCodfish

On the computer

Joined
30 Mar 06
Moves
675
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by laur3tta
it would be infinite, as your chords could be infinitely thin.
No, because they are all of the same length and can't intersect

s
Standard membersonhouse
Fast and Curious

slatington, pa, usa

Joined
28 Dec 04
Moves
53321
Clock
19 Apr 06
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Codfish
No, because they are all of the same length and can't intersect
By intersect do you mean its not allowed for even the ends of the chords to touch? I think even if that were the case you still could get an infinite #, they can asymtotically approach each other not touching, but infinitely close. Don't see a limiting factor here.
For every chord you can construct there would be a smaller one that could be fitted in the same space, ad infinitum.

f
Standard memberfrew

Joined
27 Apr 05
Moves
2580
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

i have to agree with sonhouse, i can't find anything wrong with the argument. please prove it wrong!

f
Standard memberfrew

Joined
27 Apr 05
Moves
2580
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

If I inscribe a regular N-gon in a circle of radius R then surely all of the N sides are chords. There is, however, no limit on N. So I would have to conclude the answer is infinity. Please explain to me how I am wrong

f
Standard memberfrew

Joined
27 Apr 05
Moves
2580
Clock
19 Apr 06
3 edits
Vote Up
Vote Down

Wait, unless N (the length of the chord) is fixed. in which case it is not infinity, there would have to be a relation between N and R. I'm an idiot, i just got the same answer as LemmonJello. Sorry. So in response to sonhouse draw a picture and you'll see it is not infinite, N has to be fixed.

C
Standard memberCodfish

On the computer

Joined
30 Mar 06
Moves
675
Clock
19 Apr 06
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by frew
Wait, unless N (the length of the chord) is fixed. in which case it is not infinity, there would have to be a relation between N and R. I'm an idiot, i just got the same answer as LemmonJello. Sorry. So in response to sonhouse draw a picture and you'll see it is not infinite, N has to be fixed.
Yes, N is a fixed length. Sorry for the confusion

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.