Holmes and Watson

ThudanBlunder
Posers and Puzzles 23 Aug '06 03:46
1. 23 Aug '06 03:463 edits
Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson, H and W, are told that two positive integers x and y have been chosen such that 1 < x < y and x + y < 100. H is given the value x + y and W is given the value xy. They then have the following conversation:

W: I cannot determine the two numbers.
H: I knew that.
W: Now I can determine them.
H: So can I.

Given that Holmes' and Watson's logic is impeccable and that the above statements are all true, what are the two numbers?
2. sonhouse
Fast and Curious
24 Aug '06 07:061 edit
Originally posted by ThudanBlunder
Sherlock Holmes and Dr Watson, H and W, are told that two positive integers x and y have been chosen such that 1 < x < y and x + y < 100. H is given the value x + y and W is given the value xy. They then have the following conversation:

W: I cannot determine the two numbers.
H: I knew that.
W: Now I can determine them.
H: So on's logic is impeccable and that the above statements are all true, what are the two numbers?
Great problem, got a chuckle from me! No idea how to actually solve it!
Ah, simultaneous equations.
3. XanthosNZ
Cancerous Bus Crash
24 Aug '06 08:45
Originally posted by sonhouse
Great problem, got a chuckle from me! No idea how to actually solve it!
Ah, simultaneous equations.
The problem here isn't the simultaneous equations but the logical conditions that Holmes and Watson demonstrate. Holmes knows that Watson cannot solve the equations just based on the information he is given and once Watson knows that that is the case then he can solve the system. And once Holmes knows that Watson can now solve it so can he.
4. 24 Aug '06 09:02
x=4; y=13
I could explain it, but it'd take a while... ðŸ˜‰
5. BigDoggProblem
Just...the Dogg
24 Aug '06 21:26
Originally posted by Kipyusha
x=4; y=13
I could explain it, but it'd take a while... ðŸ˜‰
Explanation and lengthy discussion on this problem can be found in .