Go back
Octahedron and Cube

Octahedron and Cube

Posers and Puzzles

Vote Up
Vote Down

A cube has 12 edges; an octahedron has 12 edges.
A cube has 8 vertexes; an octahedron has 8 faces.
A cube has 6 faces; an octahedron has 6 vertexes.
Each face of a cube has 4 sides; each vertex of an octahedron touches 4 edges.
Each vertex of a cube touches 3 edges; each face of an octahedron has 3 sides.

So, cubes and octahedrons have something to do with each other.

Do tetrahedrons or icosahedrons have a similar pair?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by talzamir
A cube has 12 edges; an octahedron has 12 edges.
A cube has 8 vertexes; an octahedron has 8 faces.
A cube has 6 faces; an octahedron has 6 vertexes.
Each face of a cube has 4 sides; each vertex of an octahedron touches 4 edges.
Each vertex of a cube touches 3 edges; each face of an octahedron has 3 sides.

So, cubes and octahedrons have something to do with each other.

Do tetrahedrons or icosahedrons have a similar pair?
So in the case of the tetrahedron, are we looking for a corresponding polyhedron whose edges are 6, faces are 4, vertexes are 4, sides of each face are 3, and each face has 3 sides?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Indeed we are. The case for a tetrahedron is pretty obvious.. the icosahedron perhaps a bit less so.

A tetrahedron has 6 edges; a ? has 12 edges.
A tetrahedron has 4 vertexes; a ? has 8 faces.
A tetrahedron has 4 faces; a ? has 4 vertexes.
Each face of a tetraedron has 3 sides; each vertex of a ? touches 3 edges.
Each vertex of a tetrahedron touches 3 edges; each face of a ? has 3 sides.

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Oops. That's what I get from posting in a hurry. The above should read,

A tetrahedron has 6 edges; a ? has 6 edges.
A tetrahedron has 4 vertexes; a ? has 4 faces.
A tetrahedron has 4 faces; a ? has 4 vertexes.
Each face of a tetraedron has 3 sides; each vertex of a ? touches 3 edges.
Each vertex of a tetrahedron touches 3 edges; each face of a ? has 3 sides.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by talzamir
A cube has 12 edges; an octahedron has 12 edges.
A cube has 8 vertexes; an octahedron has 8 faces.
A cube has 6 faces; an octahedron has 6 vertexes.
Each face of a cube has 4 sides; each vertex of an octahedron touches 4 edges.
Each vertex of a cube touches 3 edges; each face of an octahedron has 3 sides.

So, cubes and octahedrons have something to do with each other.

Do tetrahedrons or icosahedrons have a similar pair?
Shades of Escher!

Although I don't think he used the icosahedron case - but he did use the tetrahedron one to great effect.

Richard

Vote Up
Vote Down

Indeed he did. An art gallery here was once filled with the works of Escher - a real delight. =)

As for the puzzle.. a tetrahedron (a four-sided die or D4) flips into another tetrahedron. A cube and an octahedron (d6 and d8) convert into each other. An icosahedron (D12) flips into a dodecahedron (D20). When I saw that I was rather stunned about it, and wondered why it works so. There is a clear reason for it.

Some gamers also use a ten-side die (D10) that looks like two pyramids of a base and five sides each, with the bases glued together. It has seven vertexes, ten faces, and 15 edges. It converts into a cylinder with a pentagon as base. 15 edges, 7 faces, 10 vertexes. In that, not every face looks the same, but then, the d10 is not one of Plato's perfect five.

Vote Up
Vote Down

The reason.. if you take the center point each face of a polyhedron and assign that as a vertex, and make an edge where two faces are adjacent, you get a face where the vertexes were. That projection converts
* vertexes into faces and vice versa
* maintains the number of edges
* replaces the number of sides of each face by edges from a vertex and vice versa

So a tetrahedron becomes a tetrahedron, a cube an octahedron, a dodecahedron an icosahedron, and vice versa.