05 Dec '07 15:35

Given a circle with inscribed equilateral triangle, what is the probability that a randomly chosen chord is longer than the side of the triangle.

- Joined
- 14 Dec '05
- Moves
- 5692

- Joined
- 06 Mar '07
- Moves
- 1476

05 Dec '07 16:47

I'm not normally great with geometrical problems but I'll give this a go. I apologise if it's unclear or messy.*Originally posted by luskin***Given a circle with inscribed equilateral triangle, what is the probability that a randomly chosen chord is longer than the side of the triangle.**

Take a semi-circle with one corner of the equilateral triangle as a corner of the semi-circle. The line of the triangle then creates an angle of 30 degrees from the base of the semi-circle. Any randomly chosen chord from the corner of the semi-circle must make an angle between 0 and 90 degrees from the base. If the angle is >0 and 30 and- Joined
- 14 Feb '04
- Moves
- 28719

False berry05 Dec '07 17:33

Looks like you got cut off, but I think you're saying the same thing I was thinking. Call the points of the triangle A, B and C. If you start your chord on A, then only if the endpoint lies inside the arc formed by B and C will the chord be longer than the side of the triangle. Since the length of arc BC is 1/3 of the total circumference, the probability that a random chord will be longer than the side of the triangle is also 1/3.*Originally posted by PaddyB***I'm not normally great with geometrical problems but I'll give this a go. I apologise if it's unclear or messy.**

Take a semi-circle with one corner of the equilateral triangle as a corner of the semi-circle. The line of the triangle then creates an angle of 30 degrees from the base of the semi-circle. Any randomly chosen chord from the corner of the semi-ci ...[text shortened]... cle must make an angle between 0 and 90 degrees from the base. If the angle is >0 and 30 and- Joined
- 14 Dec '05
- Moves
- 5692

05 Dec '07 23:41

That looks right. But what about this? Every chord has a unique mid-point, so you could choose a random point to determine your chord, and that mid-point would need to be within the inner concentric circle, which has half the radius of the original. This suggests probability of 1/4.*Originally posted by PBE6***Looks like you got cut off, but I think you're saying the same thing I was thinking. Call the points of the triangle A, B and C. If you start your chord on A, then only if the endpoint lies inside the arc formed by B and C will the chord be longer than the side of the triangle. Since the length of arc BC is 1/3 of the total circumference, the probability that a random chord will be longer than the side of the triangle is also 1/3.**- Joined
- 23 Aug '04
- Moves
- 24791

tinyurl.com/y2c6j2t306 Dec '07 04:531 editIf you start at one of the vertices, then 60 degrees are within the triangle, and there are a total of 180 degrees (with 0 degrees and 180 degrees producing chords with length 0).

The chords that are "inside" the triangle will be longer than the sides of the triangle, while the others will not be. So I agree - 1/3- Joined
- 23 Aug '04
- Moves
- 24791

tinyurl.com/y2c6j2t306 Dec '07 05:15

The midpoint does not need to be inside an inner concentric circle with half the radius of the original. For example, a chord at 1 degree will not have such a midpoint.*Originally posted by luskin***That looks right. But what about this? Every chord has a unique mid-point, so you could choose a random point to determine your chord, and that mid-point would need to be within the inner concentric circle, which has half the radius of the original. This suggests probability of 1/4.**- Joined
- 14 Dec '05
- Moves
- 5692

06 Dec '07 08:48

What I meant is if the chord is to be longer than the`side of the triangle, then the mid-point must be within the inner circle.*Originally posted by AThousandYoung***The midpoint does not need to be inside an inner concentric circle with half the radius of the original. For example, a chord at 1 degree will not have such a midpoint.**- Joined
- 12 Mar '02
- Moves
- 15128

Your Blackened Sky06 Dec '07 09:50

No, as there is more than one chord going through the mid point. In fact, if you take the area of the centre of the circle to be infinite (that is, there are infinitly many lengths of chords) then there is infinitly many chords of length=the diameter of the circle, and the infinity mucks everything up.*Originally posted by luskin***That looks right. But what about this? Every chord has a unique mid-point, so you could choose a random point to determine your chord, and that mid-point would need to be within the inner concentric circle, which has half the radius of the original. This suggests probability of 1/4.**

What you have outlined, I think, is the probabiliy of a chord of length x where (size of side of triangle- Joined
- 07 Sep '05
- Moves
- 35068

06 Dec '07 10:43It does look like the answer is going to depend on the probability distribution.

Do you consider the distribution to be even with respect to the angle of the chord, the end point around the circumference of the circle, the midpoint of the chord within the circle, or something else? They'll each give you a different answer.- Joined
- 12 Mar '02
- Moves
- 15128

Your Blackened Sky06 Dec '07 11:43

ah-I was cut off. You have calculated the probability of chords of length greater than or equal to the length of the side of the triangle and strictly less than the diameter of the circle.*Originally posted by genius***No, as there is more than one chord going through the mid point. In fact, if you take the area of the centre of the circle to be infinite (that is, there are infinitly many lengths of chords) then there is infinitly many chords of length=the diameter of the circle, and the infinity mucks everything up.**

What you have outlined, I think, is the probabiliy of a chord of length x where (size of side of triangle- Joined
- 07 Sep '05
- Moves
- 35068

06 Dec '07 11:58

But what is the probability of a random chord going through the centre? Or any other randomly chosen point? It's going to be zero, isn't it?*Originally posted by genius***ah-I was cut off. You have calculated the probability of chords of length greater than or equal to the length of the side of the triangle and strictly less than the diameter of the circle.**

Or to use a bit of jargon, the chord will*almost surely*not go through the centre.- Joined
- 14 Feb '04
- Moves
- 28719

False berry06 Dec '07 16:42

That same argument applies to any point you care to choose. However, it doesn't matter where the mid-point of a random chord*Originally posted by mtthw***But what is the probability of a random chord going through the centre? Or any other randomly chosen point? It's going to be zero, isn't it?**

Or to use a bit of jargon, the chord will*almost surely*not go through the centre.*may*lie when describing all points where the mid-points of all possible chords*do*lie. The problem arises when each point corresponds to a different number of chords.

As genius pointed out, there are an infinite number of chords that have their mid-points at the centre so there is a problem with double counting. Fixing one point of the chord on the edge, and then sweeping out all possible chords in order, alleviates this problem.

After doing a Monte Carlo simulation on Excel, by placing 5000 random pairs of points on a circle with radius 1 and calculating the distance between them, the result was that about 36% of the time the chord was longer than the side of the triangle. This is a little higher than 1/3, which makes me think the random number generator on Excel is a little wonky. Either that or there's more to this problem than meets the eye.- Joined
- 07 Sep '05
- Moves
- 35068

06 Dec '07 17:091 edit

Yes, it does apply to any point. But it still suggests you can except any single point without affecting the final answer.*Originally posted by PBE6***That same argument applies to any point you care to choose. However, it doesn't matter where the mid-point of a random chord***may*lie when describing all points where the mid-points of all possible chords*do*lie. The problem arises when each point corresponds to a different number of chords.

As genius pointed out, there are an infinite number ...[text shortened]... r on Excel is a little wonky. Either that or there's more to this problem than meets the eye.

For the second bit: as I said before, there are several ways of defining your distribution. You've chosen a sensible one, but there are others.- Joined
- 14 Feb '04
- Moves
- 28719

False berry06 Dec '07 17:25

I agree you can*Originally posted by mtthw***Yes, it does apply to any point. But it still suggests you can except any single point without affecting the final answer.**

For the second bit: as I said before, there are several ways of defining your distribution. You've chosen a sensible one, but there are others.*normally*leave out any single point without affecting the final answer in these types of questions, but you can't leave out a singularity with infinite weighting while every other point has finite weighting!- Joined
- 09 Jun '07
- Moves
- 46061

at home