1. Subscribertalzamir
    Art, not a Toil
    60.13N / 25.01E
    Joined
    19 Sep '11
    Moves
    45045
    13 Oct '11 10:52
    There are three dice, with different numbers on each side.

    A: 1-1-5-5-5-5
    B: 2-2-2-2-6-6
    C: 3-3-3-4-4-4


    Two players each choose one of the three dice, and roll once; high roll wins. You get to / have the misfortune to go first. Which of the three dice should you choose?

    Follow-up; is it possible to make a perfect set of dice like these, so that

    * P(A defeats B) = P(B defeats C) = P(C defeats A) = P > 1/2
    * all 18 numbers are natural numbers
    * no ties can happen; and
    * the average of the numbers on the six sides of each die is the same?

    If there are multiple such solutions, how high can P be?

    If it is not possible, why not? Perhaps it could be done with dice with a number of sides other than six?
  2. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16018
    13 Oct '11 15:191 edit
    Originally posted by talzamir
    There are three dice, with different numbers on each side.

    A: 1-1-5-5-5-5
    B: 2-2-2-2-6-6
    C: 3-3-3-4-4-4


    Two players each choose one of the three dice, and roll once; high roll wins. You get to / have the misfortune to go first. Which of the three dice should you choose?

    Follow-up; is it possible to make a perfect set of dice like these, so that ...[text shortened]... not possible, why not? Perhaps it could be done with dice with a number of sides other than six?
    The worse case scenarios for each die:
    A: Reveal Hidden Content
    4/9 vs B

    B: Reveal Hidden Content
    1/3 vs C

    C: Reveal Hidden Content
    1/3 vs A


    One of things things are not like the others 🙂
  3. Joined
    10 Jan '08
    Moves
    10277
    13 Oct '11 15:301 edit
    I pick A.

    Edit: although, B probably has a slight edge over A in the long run with A having a slight edge over C and C having a slight edge over B.

    I still pick A, I'd rather have AvsB than have BvsC. No one is going to pick C first.
  4. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16018
    13 Oct '11 20:181 edit
    Originally posted by Trev33

    I still pick A, I'd rather have AvsB than have BvsC. No one is going to pick C first.
    C vs A is identical to B vs C, why would you pick either one?
  5. Joined
    10 Jan '08
    Moves
    10277
    15 Oct '11 18:06
    Originally posted by forkedknight
    C vs A is identical to B vs C, why would you pick either one?
    If i pick C they're going to pick A and if i pick B they're going to pick C. Picking A is the only logical choice to go against their B. I have 4 sides that'll beat 4 B sides, granted B has the same but it's a lot better odds in a one off roll than any of the other possibilities for one roll.
  6. Subscribertalzamir
    Art, not a Toil
    60.13N / 25.01E
    Joined
    19 Sep '11
    Moves
    45045
    15 Oct '11 18:17
    As pointed out by forkedknight:

    A vs B: A wins with a five over two probability 2/3 x 2/3 = 4/9
    B vs C: B wins with a six over any, probability 1/3 x 3/3 = 3/9
    C vs A: C wins with any over one, probability 3/3 x 1/3 = 3/9

    so A is the best choice. I would like to have a set like this where it doesn't matter what the first player picks, the odds are always worse than 50% and always the same. With these exact dice, the odds are not identical.

    Can these dice be somehow fixed?
  7. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16018
    16 Oct '11 19:34
    A: Reveal Hidden Content
    1-1-5-5-9-9

    B: Reveal Hidden Content
    3-3-4-4-8-8

    C: Reveal Hidden Content
    2-2-6-6-7-7
  8. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16018
    17 Oct '11 20:43
    Option #2 (P = 17/36)
    A: Reveal Hidden Content
    1-6-7-11-15-17

    B: Reveal Hidden Content
    2-4-8-12-13-18

    C: Reveal Hidden Content
    3-5-9-10-14-16
Back to Top