Stupid Mind Game 6

here are 2 people named jack and john. both of them have split personalities. jack in his normal state always tells the truth and in his altered state always tells lies, john in his normal state always tells a lie and in his altered state always tells the truth.

What simple yes or no question could you ask to find out waht state their in?

Please clarify - if John is in his altered state, is Jim also necessarily in his altered state?

lol....just read this on this site like 2 days ago 🙂

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
Please clarify - if John is in his altered state, is Jim also necessarily in his altered state?

no. although they could be...

Originally posted by jvanhine
lol....just read this on this site like 2 days ago 🙂

ya this is slightly different

Are you Jack?

Either one in their normal state would say "yes;" either one in their altered state would say "no." Reverse the responses if you ask, "Are you John?"

Originally posted by Jirakon
Are you Jack?

Either one in their normal state would say "yes;" either one in their altered state would say "no." Reverse the responses if you ask, "Are you John?"

ya but how do you know which one is jack and which one is john.

Do they have name tags?

Originally posted by uzless
ya but how do you know which one is jack and which one is john.

Do they have name tags?

Are they neccessarily different people? Jack in his altered state sounds pretty much like John to me.

Originally posted by DeepThought
Are they neccessarily different people? Jack in his altered state sounds pretty much like John to me.

Dance Master MC said there are 2 people with split personalities, so I'm guessing yes.

Originally posted by uzless
ya but how do you know which one is jack and which one is john.

Do they have name tags?

The question was "What simple yes or no question could you ask to find out what state they're in?

Why do you care what their names are?

ok, then lets change their names to brittany and maddona

Originally posted by jvanhine
ok, then lets change their names to brittany and maddona

3rd time I have had to say this to you😞

funny, but wtf?.....😛

Originally posted by Dance Master MC
here are 2 people named jack and john. both of them have split personalities. jack in his normal state always tells the truth and in his altered state always tells lies, john in his normal state always tells a lie and in his altered state always tells the truth.

What simple yes or no question could you ask to find out waht state their in?

Do you like ice cream? Because everyone loves ice cream.

no. not even close to the answer, I'm sorry to say that wasn't even a good guess😞

Originally posted by Dance Master MC
no. not even close to the answer, I'm sorry to say that wasn't even a good guess😞

What was wrong with the question "Are you Jack?"