Go back
Subsets

Subsets

Posers and Puzzles

m

Joined
04 Jul 04
Moves
3592
Clock
23 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Seems therere quite a few mathappreciative people here.
So here is quite elegant problem for them.

Proove that every set ot ten different numbers (chosen from ste {1,2,...,100}) contains two disjoint nonempty subsets of the same sum.

Good luck,
madoldman.

Acolyte
Now With Added BA

Loughborough

Joined
04 Jul 02
Moves
3790
Clock
27 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Let A be a subset of {1,2,...,100} of size 10. Then A has 1022 proper subsets (ie ones which aren't A or empty), and given a proper subset, the sum of its elements must be a positive integer, bounded above by 100*9 = 900. So by the pigeon-hole principle we can find distinct proper subsets B and C with Sum(B) = Sum(C)

B cannot be a subset of C, because if it was, then Sum(C) >= Sum(B) + x for some x>0 in C\B, so Sum(C) > Sum(B); similarly B doesn't contain C. Hence the sets B\C and C\B are nonempty.
Sum(B\C) = Sum(B) - Sum(BnC) = Sum(C) - Sum(CnB) = Sum(C\B)

Therefore B\C and C\B are disjoint nonempty subsets of A with the same sum.

m

Joined
04 Jul 04
Moves
3592
Clock
28 Nov 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Very clean job, Acolyte!

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.