Posers and Puzzles

Posers and Puzzles

  1. SubscriberKewpie
    since 1-Feb-07
    Joined
    20 Jan '09
    Moves
    324743
    10 Dec '11 11:55
    I can't even do high school maths, but this one always bothered me.

    1/9 equals 0.11111111111111111 forever
    2/9 equals 0.22222222222222222 forever
    3/9 equals 0.33333333333333333 forever
    ...
    9/9 must equal 0.9999999999999999 forever

    But 9/9 equals 1 ! How is this so?
  2. Joined
    26 Apr '03
    Moves
    26517
    10 Dec '11 16:00
    Originally posted by Kewpie
    I can't even do high school maths, but this one always bothered me.

    1/9 equals 0.11111111111111111 forever
    2/9 equals 0.22222222222222222 forever
    3/9 equals 0.33333333333333333 forever
    ...
    9/9 must equal 0.9999999999999999 forever

    But 9/9 equals 1 ! How is this so?
    x = 0.999999999

    10x = 9.99999999

    10x - x = 9x = 9.9999999 - 0.999999999 = 9

    so
    9x = 9

    x = 1

    9/9 = 0.9999999999999 = 1
  3. Joined
    12 Mar '03
    Moves
    37834
    11 Dec '11 11:451 edit
    Originally posted by iamatiger
    x = 0.999999999

    10x = 9.99999999

    10x - x = 9x = 9.9999999 - 0.999999999 = 9

    so
    9x = 9

    x = 1

    9/9 = 0.9999999999999 = 1
    ?

    sorry

    x = 0.999999999

    10x = 9.99999999

    10x - x = 9x = 9.9999999 - 0.999999999 = 8.99999991 which is not 9.

    Or what?

    Just to say that the infinite recurrence of the 9's is the crucial point.
  4. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16169
    11 Dec '11 16:04
    Originally posted by Mephisto2


    10x - x = 9x = 9.9999999 - 0.999999999 = 8.99999991 which is not 9.

    Or what?

    Just to say that the infinite recurrence of the 9's is the crucial point.
    Using what math does

    9.999... - 0.999... = 8.99999999991

    ?
  5. Joined
    12 Mar '03
    Moves
    37834
    11 Dec '11 18:301 edit
    Originally posted by forkedknight
    Using what math does

    9.999... - 0.999... = 8.99999999991
    because in Iamatiger's answer, there were no '.....' after the 9's. Try it on your calculator.
    ?
    because in Iamatiger's answer, there were no '.....' after the 9's.
  6. Joined
    26 Apr '03
    Moves
    26517
    11 Dec '11 19:57
    I couldn't get a 9 with a dot over it, which is how I would usually write "recurring". I assumed everybody would know what I meant, and I suspect even the quibblers did know actually!
  7. Standard membersmw6869
    Granny
    Parts Unknown
    Joined
    19 Jan '07
    Moves
    73089
    11 Dec '11 22:51
    Originally posted by Kewpie
    I can't even do high school maths, but this one always bothered me.

    1/9 equals 0.11111111111111111 forever
    2/9 equals 0.22222222222222222 forever
    3/9 equals 0.33333333333333333 forever
    ...
    9/9 must equal 0.9999999999999999 forever

    But 9/9 equals 1 ! How is this so?
    I remember this from High School: Any number divided by itself equals 1. Case closed. Them's the rules.


    GRANNY.
  8. SubscriberKewpie
    since 1-Feb-07
    Joined
    20 Jan '09
    Moves
    324743
    11 Dec '11 23:04
    The way I understood it, any recurring digit approaches the next whole number but can never quite reach it, so 0.9 recurring can never quite equal 1. That makes the thing paradoxical to me. Perhaps the problem is at the other end: maybe 1/9 doesn't really equal 0.1 recurring, perhaps it's just "near enough". And that minuscule difference is always there but ignored by everybody.
  9. Joined
    18 Jan '07
    Moves
    7488
    12 Dec '11 19:38
    Originally posted by Kewpie
    The way I understood it, any recurring digit approaches the next whole number but can never quite reach it, so 0.9 recurring can never quite equal 1.
    Then you understood it wrong. 0.9 recurring is, in fact, quite equal to 1.

    Richard
  10. SubscriberKewpie
    since 1-Feb-07
    Joined
    20 Jan '09
    Moves
    324743
    12 Dec '11 20:35
    It seems to me that there's a circular argument here. I say 0.9 recurring tends to 1 but can never equal 1. You say 0.9 does equal one. Any proof using fractions doesn't make it so, because recurring numbers aren't able to be resolved this side of infinity.

    We aren't the only ones having this discussion:

    http://forum.boagworld.com/discussion/596/is-0.9-recurring-equal-to-one-the-big-debate/p1
  11. Joined
    26 Apr '03
    Moves
    26517
    12 Dec '11 20:39
    There are (at least) two ways of representing 1/9
    1/9 and 0.1111111111(1), these are exactly equal


    Similarly for 2/9 = 0.22222222(2), 3/9, 4/9 etc

    So 9.9 is not an oddity. if you say that 0.99999(9) <> 9/9 then you are also claiming that 0.11111111(1) /= 1/9

    Another looking at it is the power of infinity, as we add more 9s to the end of 0.9 we are 1/10^n away from 9/9, and n increases with each 9 we add

    In the limit, we are 1/n^(infinity) away from 9/9 and 1/infinity = 0
  12. Standard memberforkedknight
    Defend the Universe
    127.0.0.1
    Joined
    18 Dec '03
    Moves
    16169
    12 Dec '11 21:311 edit
    Originally posted by iamatiger

    In the limit, we are 1/n^(infinity) away from 9/9 and 1/infinity = 0
    So long as we are nit-picking

    1/infinity is not equal to 0. Infinity is not a number and cannot be used as a number in an equation. Several laws of mathematics break down if you attempt this.

    It is correct to say that

    1/n as n->infinity approaches 0
  13. Standard membertalzamir
    Art, not a Toil
    60.13N / 25.01E
    Joined
    19 Sep '11
    Moves
    46194
    13 Dec '11 11:06
    One way to think of it, of course, is as a sum of 0.9 x 10^(-n) where n gets the values 1, 2, 3, ..., that is 0.9 + 0.09 + 0.009 + ...

    Wonder if it is more convincing to ask how much 0.9999... differs from 1?

    And that would be by 0.00000000.....

    so.. not by very much.


    While on the topic of sums... can you evaluate

    1 - 1/2 + 1/3 - 1/4 + 1/5 - ..... + (-1)^n / n + ... ?
  14. Subscriberjoe shmo
    Strange Egg
    podunk, PA
    Joined
    10 Dec '06
    Moves
    7733
    13 Dec '11 23:313 edits
    Originally posted by talzamir
    One way to think of it, of course, is as a sum of 0.9 x 10^(-n) where n gets the values 1, 2, 3, ..., that is 0.9 + 0.09 + 0.009 + ...

    Wonder if it is more convincing to ask how much 0.9999... differs from 1?

    And that would be by 0.00000000.....

    so.. not by very much.


    While on the topic of sums... can you evaluate

    1 - 1/2 + 1/3 - 1/4 + 1/5 - ..... + (-1)^n / n + ... ?
    I think its the golden ratio, which in this case

    = -(1- Sqrt(5))/2

    and wouldn't the n th term be

    ((-1)^(n+1))/n
  15. Wat?
    Joined
    16 Aug '05
    Moves
    76863
    14 Dec '11 14:10
    Originally posted by Shallow Blue
    Then you understood it wrong. 0.9 recurring is, in fact, quite equal to 1.

    Richard
    I think you're right, but didn't explain it in a more simplistic way.

    A picturing point of view is for repetitive halfs which could be endless, and yet we know there is an end.

    Consider the analogy of throwing a stone into the air. We know to come down, it must come half way as high as it went. It must come half way again, and then half of that distance again. Each half distance it travels has to go on and on, and it is always travelling half way.

    Of course, we hear the sound of the stone hitting the floor or rock upon which it lands and so, therefore, this infinite half way argument is flawed, same as 0.9 recurring doesn't = 1.

    -m. 😉
Back to Top