# Who is the smartest?

elopawn
Posers and Puzzles 27 Oct '05 06:12
1. 27 Oct '05 06:12
A king had 3 advisors and he wanted to find out who was the smartest. So he devised a test for them. He said that he had 3 white hats and 2 black hats. After seating the three men facing each other, he told them that he would randomly pick 3 hats, which would be placed on their heads so that they could each see the other 2 men's hats but not their own. Unbeknownst to them, the king tossed away the two black hats and only used the three white hats. After staring at each other for a while, one of the wise men figured it out and shouted, "I know! My hat is white!" How did he do it?
2. XanthosNZ
Cancerous Bus Crash
27 Oct '05 06:19
Originally posted by elopawn
A king had 3 advisors and he wanted to find out who was the smartest. So he devised a test for them. He said that he had 3 white hats and 2 black hats. After seating the three men facing each other, he told them that he would randomly pick 3 hats, which would be placed on their heads so that they could each see the other 2 men's hats but not their own. Unbe ...[text shortened]... , one of the wise men figured it out and shouted, "I know! My hat is white!" How did he do it?
Neither of the other two advisors can see two black hats because otherwise they would know their hat colour is white.

If either of the other advisors could see a single black hat they would know that their hat was white as if it wasn't then the white hat wearing advisor would see two black hats and know his hat was white.

As neither of these has happened his own hat must be white.
3. 27 Oct '05 06:341 edit
Originally posted by XanthosNZ
Neither of the other two advisors can see two black hats because otherwise they would know their hat colour is white.

If either of the other advisors could see a single black hat they would know that their hat was white as if it wasn't then the white hat wearing advisor would see two black hats and know his hat was white.

As neither of these has happened his own hat must be white.
A further small question:

Which advisor would you perfer to be in this situation? Or do you think that it doesn't matter?
4. XanthosNZ
Cancerous Bus Crash
27 Oct '05 07:07
Originally posted by elopawn
A further small question:

Which advisor would you perfer to be in this situation? Or do you think that it doesn't matter?
All advisors can follow the same logic and reach the conclusion. However to do so you must have confidence in your fellow advisors. If one advisor is much worse than the others that is the one to be.
5. Nemesio
Ursulakantor
27 Oct '05 07:58
Originally posted by elopawn
A further small question:

Which advisor would you perfer to be in this situation?
The smart one!

Or is this a trick question? ðŸ˜‰

Nemesio
6. 27 Oct '05 14:29
Originally posted by elopawn
A king had 3 advisors and he wanted to find out who was the smartest. So he devised a test for them. He said that he had 3 white hats and 2 black hats. After seating the three men facing each other, he told them that he would randomly pick 3 hats, which would be placed on their heads so that they could each see the other 2 men's hats but not their own. Unbe ...[text shortened]... , one of the wise men figured it out and shouted, "I know! My hat is white!" How did he do it?
He diden't, It was a gamble.
7. gaurav2711
walking...
27 Oct '05 14:49
Originally posted by LordOfTheChessboard
He diden't, It was a gamble.
it was a gamble....but as Xanthos mentioned, it is an educated gamble. Obviously he knew that the other 2 advisors were smart enuff to call White if they saw a black hat. However, he was jus that touch smarter.
8. 27 Oct '05 14:591 edit
Originally posted by gaurav2711
it was a gamble....but as Xanthos mentioned, it is an educated gamble. Obviously he knew that the other 2 advisors were smart enuff to call White if they saw a black hat. However, he was jus that touch smarter.
Wise man dont gamble!

They say: I cannot know.
9. Bowmann
Non-Subscriber
27 Oct '05 18:581 edit
10. AThousandYoung
27 Oct '05 22:56
Originally posted by Bowmann

11. Bowmann
Non-Subscriber
27 Oct '05 23:32
Originally posted by AThousandYoung

Like many dictionaries on the Web, this is American. To most people it's useless.
12. gaurav2711
walking...
28 Oct '05 07:07
Originally posted by Bowmann
Like many dictionaries on the Web, this is American. To most people it's useless.
oxford aint american. ðŸ˜› check this out.

cheers!!
13. BigDoggProblem
Just...the Dogg
28 Oct '05 18:47
Originally posted by Bowmann
Like many dictionaries on the Web, this is American. To most people it's useless.
U.S. Population: ~300 million.
U.K. Population: ~60 million.
14. 28 Oct '05 19:39
Originally posted by BigDoggProblem
U.S. Population: ~300 million.
U.K. Population: ~60 million.
I do believe you are not counting the millions of people in europe who speak english as a second language...
15. Bowmann
Non-Subscriber
28 Oct '05 23:14
Originally posted by gaurav2711