Originally posted by PinkFloydI think there are experiments from astronomy that shows the speed of light back near the BB was very close to today. I will have to google it to find out exactly but the idea of the variable C is to take in to account the era of super fast inflation right after the BB, which is a theory but with a lot of evidence supporting it.
I watched "Jose Magueijo's Big Bang" last night on one of the science channels, and learned that this Variable Spped of Light theory is an alternative to something called Inflation theory. It seems that both are trying to address a "fatal flaw" in the Big Bang theory. As I understand it, all the stuff in the universe should be randomly distributed as a r watched the Twilight Zone; it was the one where Mickey Rooney played a jockey..... π
Here is a wiki link, its a bit long but the one in question is the last piece, "variable speed of light cosmology". That''s just a 50 cent tour though.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable_speed_of_light
Originally posted by twhiteheadFor a photon time stands still. There is no motion to a photon due to the aforementioned time dilation.
If a photon is moving away from me at velocity C then am I not moving away from it at velocity C or is that not the case because of the time dilation experienced by the photon?
Originally posted by AThousandYoungBut that means that from the photons perspective my velocity relative to it exceeds C. In fact if the photons time stands still then my velocity is infinite!
For a photon time stands still. There is no motion to a photon due to the aforementioned time dilation.
Also, if I am moving away from the photon at speed C relative to the photon, why does my time not dilate too?
Originally posted by twhiteheadIf you are moving at C with respect to a photon, it means you have no mass, its that simple. You have mass, therefore you cannot go at C. Its like trying to swim through molassas.
But that means that from the photons perspective my velocity relative to it exceeds C. In fact if the photons time stands still then my velocity is infinite!
Also, if I am moving away from the photon at speed C relative to the photon, why does my time not dilate too?
Originally posted by joe shmoWould that book be 'The Trouble With Physics' by Lee Smolin by any chance?
we can blame string theory for occupying all the physicists at least that is what the book I'm reading says...lol
He rips and snorts against string theory that it doesn't make predictions and complains it is taking away resources from other work.
I think he is a bit premature, look at the time it took to go from Newton to Einstein.
Originally posted by sonhouseI thought everything was relative, so if the photon is moving away from me at C then I am moving away from it at C.
If you are moving at C with respect to a photon, it means you have no mass, its that simple. You have mass, therefore you cannot go at C. Its like trying to swim through molassas.
Originally posted by twhiteheadA photon will move away from you at C regardless of your velocity.
I thought everything was relative, so if the photon is moving away from me at C then I am moving away from it at C.
If you are going backwards away from the photon in question at 0.9999C, the photon is still going away from you at C, not 1.999C, those velocities don't just add together.
Originally posted by twhiteheadNo, it means that from the photon's perspective nothing moves at all since there's no such thing as time.
But that means that from the photons perspective my velocity relative to it exceeds C. In fact if the photons time stands still then my velocity is infinite!
Also, if I am moving away from the photon at speed C relative to the photon, why does my time not dilate too?
Originally posted by sonhouseRight on he moneyπ
Would that book be 'The Trouble With Physics' by Lee Smolin by any chance?
He rips and snorts against string theory that it doesn't make predictions and complains it is taking away resources from other work.
I think he is a bit premature, look at the time it took to go from Newton to Einstein.