13 Oct '06 06:41>
This came up in the Evolution thread but is really unrelated to evolution so I have started a new thread.
I have started similar threads before but for some reason I get very few takers.
Originally posted by Penguin
Not sure what you mean by divisibility. I suspect the religious will have some distinction between conciousness and 'soul'.
I see 2 possibilities.
1. Each soul is eternal (has always been and will always be) and our time on Earth is a brief moment in this existance. That implies either that there is a fixed limit to the number of people that can exist, or we re-incarnate and some souls get mutliple lives, or there is an infinite supply of souls and some never get a go.
2. Each soul is created when the 'host' body is conceived or born (or some time over the next months and years as research suggests is the case with conciousness). In which case surely it must cease to exist when the host body dies.
Of course there's always the 3rd possibility: there is no such thing as a 'soul'.
--- Penguin
By divisibility I mean that if the soul is assigned at conception then twins either share a soul or the soul divided. If the soul is assigned at birth then if we divide a human brain in two and place one half in another body (theoretically possible) then the same would apply. People with dual personalities suffer from the same issue.
I would also like to know whether Christians believe that conciousness remains with the soul and if so is it a continuation of thier conciousness from the point of death or some new conciousness. If the claim is that it doesnt then how does the soul experience emotions(such as pain and anguish mentioned in hell and happiness in heaven)?
What is the definition of 'life' in christian language because the soul does not fit any of the requirements of the word in scientific language (reproduction etc). In fact in scientific language it doesnt even 'exist' if it doesnt take on physical form.
I have started similar threads before but for some reason I get very few takers.
Originally posted by Penguin
Not sure what you mean by divisibility. I suspect the religious will have some distinction between conciousness and 'soul'.
I see 2 possibilities.
1. Each soul is eternal (has always been and will always be) and our time on Earth is a brief moment in this existance. That implies either that there is a fixed limit to the number of people that can exist, or we re-incarnate and some souls get mutliple lives, or there is an infinite supply of souls and some never get a go.
2. Each soul is created when the 'host' body is conceived or born (or some time over the next months and years as research suggests is the case with conciousness). In which case surely it must cease to exist when the host body dies.
Of course there's always the 3rd possibility: there is no such thing as a 'soul'.
--- Penguin
By divisibility I mean that if the soul is assigned at conception then twins either share a soul or the soul divided. If the soul is assigned at birth then if we divide a human brain in two and place one half in another body (theoretically possible) then the same would apply. People with dual personalities suffer from the same issue.
I would also like to know whether Christians believe that conciousness remains with the soul and if so is it a continuation of thier conciousness from the point of death or some new conciousness. If the claim is that it doesnt then how does the soul experience emotions(such as pain and anguish mentioned in hell and happiness in heaven)?
What is the definition of 'life' in christian language because the soul does not fit any of the requirements of the word in scientific language (reproduction etc). In fact in scientific language it doesnt even 'exist' if it doesnt take on physical form.