Originally posted by knightmeister This is a failure of logic. Really, the thing which did happen, is the only thing which did happen, but we cannot be sure it is the only thing which could happen. SCOTTY
I agree , we cannot be sure but that is not what the model is saying is it? The model is a picture of determinism at work , and in determinism only one thing can happen so the name ...[text shortened]... ly is quite appropriate. Note that BOB was written on the staircase before he got into the room.
So who are you claiming is deterministic, or actualistic? No evolutionist for sure, only a christian or a muslim holds that the earth doesn't change for all time
Originally posted by scottishinnz So who are you claiming is deterministic, or actualistic? No evolutionist for sure, only a christian or a muslim holds that the earth doesn't change for all time
It's logical extrapolation of what 'free' will might look like under compatabilism.