19 Nov '09 16:54>1 edit
Originally posted by twhiteheadI don't think he was talking about saving souls. (And BTW - I thought that was the job of the deity.)
I disagree. First of all, what is a 'soul' and why is it worthy of being saved? What is a 'human' and why is it worthy of being saved?
Now suppose that you had a choice between 100 convicted murderers and a six year old girl. Would your choice of the six year old girl prove that the convicted murderers were not human?
As for the girl and the murderers - would your choice change if some of the convicted murderers were really innocent? What if the girl was your niece? (These questions are stupid - better to ask the question outright.)
Hypothetically we would all act in a courageous and reasonable fashion by carefully weighing our options. Realistically most of us would run away and leave them all to die. How are you treating your family? What do you do when your honor-student 15 year-old daughter gets pregnant? What do you say to your neighbor when it happens to his dropout drug-addict daughter? Do you support efforts to get prenatal health-care for those who have none? What about after the children are born? Are you willing to be taxed more to support those kids? Would you pay less for abortions or would pay more for living children? Are you just recommending how everyone else should act or are you willing accept the consequences of your recommendations yourself?