12 Jan '06 05:47>
I have read several times on this forum the claim that "anything that began to exist must have had a cause". Since the universe began to exist, it must therefore have a cause according to that statement. The person generally then goes on to assume that this cause is the God described by Christianity, but that's not really relevant to my point.
What about our choices? For example, suppose I choose to eat an apple instead of a pint of ice cream. The decision to eat the apple did not always exist, and therefore began to exist at some point. Doesn't that mean it must have had a cause according to the above claim? If our decisions are caused by something, they aren't truly free, are they?
What about our choices? For example, suppose I choose to eat an apple instead of a pint of ice cream. The decision to eat the apple did not always exist, and therefore began to exist at some point. Doesn't that mean it must have had a cause according to the above claim? If our decisions are caused by something, they aren't truly free, are they?