Go back
Quoting other people

Quoting other people

Spirituality


. . . instead of speaking for yourself.

What's that about?

Is some kind of "appeal to authority" (a logical fallacy) implied?

ravens on the bluegrass
got a sense for the storms
but they're not saying

barnacles go where they go
well, that's just sea life for some
those topside monkeys, though


@kevin-eleven said
. . . instead of speaking for yourself.

What's that about?

Is some kind of "appeal to authority" (a logical fallacy) implied?

ravens on the bluegrass
got a sense for the storms
but they're not saying

barnacles go where they go
well, that's just sea life for some
those topside monkeys, though
Not every post is 'making an argument'.

Sometimes you want to call attention to an interesting idea, even if that idea is external.

For making an argument, quoting a qualified authority on the subject can be helpful. I do agree that you should not expect the quote to do all the arguing for you.


@bigdogg said
Not every post is 'making an argument'.

Sometimes you want to call attention to an interesting idea, even if that idea is external.

For making an argument, quoting a qualified authority on the subject can be helpful. I do agree that you should not expect the quote to do all the arguing for you.
Yeah, and I also get that sometimes some people have had to limit their indications to a few words of well-known poetry or even the number of a joke.


17, for instance.


@Kevin-Eleven

Quoting miles and miles of Scripture I find tedious and often just skip over it, especially when it is interspersed with some strained interpretation. I think by now we all know where certain posters stand on faith vs. works; no need to keep rehashing that topic.


@moonbus said
@Kevin-Eleven

Quoting miles and miles of Scripture I find tedious and often just skip over it, especially when it is interspersed with some strained interpretation. I think by now we all know where certain posters stand on faith vs. works; no need to keep rehashing that topic.
38


forty two


@rookie54 said
forty two
No! However I would be willing to share my fish-broth with you, even if it's really just melted snow.



-Removed-
As they say in Ukraine: иди на хуй!


-Removed-
What substance do you reach for?


-Removed-
Oh I don't know, it's kind of refreshing not reading the same old lines.