Go back
The problem of goodness

The problem of goodness

Spirituality

2 edits

"The problem is not that there is evil in the world, the problem is that there is good. Because otherwise who would care? " -VM Varga (Fargo Season 3)



@dj2becker said
"The problem is not that there is evil in the world, the problem is that there is good. Because otherwise who would care? " -VM Varga (Fargo Season 3)
Notions of good and evil are functions of cultures and communities and they are also internalized by individuals and form the basis for their moral compasses.

Humans benefit from these things because we are social beings and we want and need to live communally.

Societal values and norms, along with people's moral compasses, govern human interactions and so help communities to survive and flourish.


@fmf said
Notions of good and evil are functions of cultures and communities
Upon what premise do you base that assertion?


-Removed-
Even as convoluted as the quote in the OP is, your reply is even more bizarre.

"The solution is that there is evil."? You must be confused.


@secondson said
Even as convoluted as the quote in the OP is, your reply is even more bizarre.

"The solution is that there is evil."? You must be confused.
Can you comment on why you think the OP is convoluted and bizarre?


@secondson said
Upon what premise do you base that assertion?
The premise that is laid out in the text in my post that you omitted.


Vote Up
Vote Down

@fmf said
Can you comment on why you think the OP is convoluted and bizarre?
"The problem is not that there is evil in the world, the problem is that there is good."

Sound reasoning would state, "the problem is that there is evil in the world, the solution to the problem of evil is that there is good."

"Good" overcomes evil. "Good" is never a "problem". The grammatical construct of Varga's quote undermines rational and logical thought relative to the nature and meaning of the concepts of what good and evil are in relation to each other.

And the added comment, "...otherwise who would care?", only serves to deepen the confusion generated by the suggestion that there being evil in the world is "not" the problem, but that a problem exists as a result of there being "good".

It's like throwing a curveball, but with words. You think it's coming at you along a certain trajectory, but at the end it slips right passed you.

Vote Up
Vote Down

-Removed-
Maybe I don't understand your reply. Perhaps you can deepen my comprehension and explain how your reply to the otherwise deceptive nature of Varga's assertion that evil isn't the problem, but that good is, and how your reply doesn't further add to the confusion.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@secondson said
"The problem is not that there is evil in the world, the problem is that there is good."

Sound reasoning would state, "the problem is that there is evil in the world, the solution to the problem of evil is that there is good."

"Good" overcomes evil. "Good" is never a "problem". The grammatical construct of Varga's quote undermines rational and logical thought relative ...[text shortened]... . You think it's coming at you along a certain trajectory, but at the end it slips right passed you.
Have you tackled dj2becker, the OP poster, about it?

Vote Up
Vote Down

@secondson said
"The problem is not that there is evil in the world, the problem is that there is good."

Sound reasoning would state, "the problem is that there is evil in the world, the solution to the problem of evil is that there is good."

"Good" overcomes evil. "Good" is never a "problem". The grammatical construct of Varga's quote undermines rational and logical thought relative ...[text shortened]... . You think it's coming at you along a certain trajectory, but at the end it slips right passed you.
I think in Varga’s case good was a problem to him because he had evil tendencies.


Vote Up
Vote Down

@dj2becker said
I think in Varga’s case good was a problem to him because he had evil tendencies.
Considering his thought process with regards to good and evil there's no doubt.

Vote Up
Vote Down

@fmf said
Have you tackled dj2becker, the OP poster, about it?
Have you read the thread?