18 Aug '06 12:57>
I wonder if theism, particularly of the literalist fundamentalist kind, is partially a product of the fact that the human mind has evolved to think in terms of dominance hierarchies.
In particular, I am wondering whether the devotion to God, which greatly puzzles non-adherents, is a form of submission to an abstractified alpha male in the sky, with some ideological bells and whistles attached.
Exhibit A: The very name "Islam", a key monotheistic religion, means "submission".
Exhibit B: Fundamentalists chide skeptics for their unmitigated arrogance in daring to defy a legitimate source of authority, and recommend their own humble obedience as the appropriate response.
Exhibit C: Unless one submits to the Alpha male in the sky, one will be savaged by Him--sent to hell. Compare a smaller dog rolling over and offering his bare neck to a larger dog, as an appeasement gesture. If Dogs believed in God, wouldn't they roll over cognitively as well as anatomically?
Perhaps, just as submission offers actual benefits in the animal world--a lower but safer position in the hierarchy, perhaps under the protection of the superordinate to whom one defers--it also offers perceived benefits in the abstract religio-cultural world that humans have invented.
In particular, I am wondering whether the devotion to God, which greatly puzzles non-adherents, is a form of submission to an abstractified alpha male in the sky, with some ideological bells and whistles attached.
Exhibit A: The very name "Islam", a key monotheistic religion, means "submission".
Exhibit B: Fundamentalists chide skeptics for their unmitigated arrogance in daring to defy a legitimate source of authority, and recommend their own humble obedience as the appropriate response.
Exhibit C: Unless one submits to the Alpha male in the sky, one will be savaged by Him--sent to hell. Compare a smaller dog rolling over and offering his bare neck to a larger dog, as an appeasement gesture. If Dogs believed in God, wouldn't they roll over cognitively as well as anatomically?
Perhaps, just as submission offers actual benefits in the animal world--a lower but safer position in the hierarchy, perhaps under the protection of the superordinate to whom one defers--it also offers perceived benefits in the abstract religio-cultural world that humans have invented.