19 Nov '06 19:39>
So ... it's Sunday but I had to go in to work for a few hours. I finish - except for writing up some of the details - and I'm starving so I head over to the chain Mexican restaurant around to corner. I figure I'll set at the bar, have some lunch, write my notes, and watch some football.
There's only a handful of people at the bar, and they have the Patriots vs Packers game on the TV. The bartender is a waif-like 85 lb girl - I can't see how she could possibly be old enough to legally *be* a bartender.
So I'm watching football, drinking my drink, taking notes, and after a few minutes said waif asks the guy two seats over to explain what they have to do to score a touchdown. It seems all she knows about football is the teams wear different color shirts, kicking the ball through the goalposts is a good thing, as is the elusive concept of a "touchdown".
I listen as this guys launches into a "explanation" of the game, and it occurs to me he might the worst explainer, of anything, I've ever heard. Within 5 sentences he is already mentioning "2 point conversions" and "blocking in the back". By the time I finish my lunch and leave I don't think he has actually imparted *any* actual understanding, beyond that the team in green are the Packers, and the team in white are the "Patriots".
His problems: a) he is dumb, b) he understands football, but he doesn't understand what it means to understand something. Every explanatory sentence contains a reference to something he has not yet explained, or jargon familiar to anyone who already understands the game but a complete mystery to someone who does not.
So, my questions: How long would it take to actually explain football in this situation assuming bar-waif really wanted to understand? What constructs would you start with? The definition of a sport? The concept of "points"?
My obvious assumption being that any amount of time engaged in talking with a young woman is worthwhile. 😉
There's only a handful of people at the bar, and they have the Patriots vs Packers game on the TV. The bartender is a waif-like 85 lb girl - I can't see how she could possibly be old enough to legally *be* a bartender.
So I'm watching football, drinking my drink, taking notes, and after a few minutes said waif asks the guy two seats over to explain what they have to do to score a touchdown. It seems all she knows about football is the teams wear different color shirts, kicking the ball through the goalposts is a good thing, as is the elusive concept of a "touchdown".
I listen as this guys launches into a "explanation" of the game, and it occurs to me he might the worst explainer, of anything, I've ever heard. Within 5 sentences he is already mentioning "2 point conversions" and "blocking in the back". By the time I finish my lunch and leave I don't think he has actually imparted *any* actual understanding, beyond that the team in green are the Packers, and the team in white are the "Patriots".
His problems: a) he is dumb, b) he understands football, but he doesn't understand what it means to understand something. Every explanatory sentence contains a reference to something he has not yet explained, or jargon familiar to anyone who already understands the game but a complete mystery to someone who does not.
So, my questions: How long would it take to actually explain football in this situation assuming bar-waif really wanted to understand? What constructs would you start with? The definition of a sport? The concept of "points"?
My obvious assumption being that any amount of time engaged in talking with a young woman is worthwhile. 😉