Originally posted by Zahlanzi
I hate threads that just give youtubes. i apologize for starting one.
Following is a scene from the show Newsroom, which i never watched but i am planing to because of this particular scene. it is a summary of what is believed to be wrong with it.
The conclusion is "America is not the greatest country in the world, but it used to be"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPHSXUS0_1c
That scene was good, though I'm a little disappointed with The Newsroom. I love everything Aaron Sorkin, and while The Newsroom is watchable, it isn't fit to carry The West Wing's jock strap. It's not just the stink of the super duper left wing politics that brings the show down (The West Wing is Fox News compared to this show). It's also that the dialogue is not quite as crisp and the stories not as compelling. Aaron Sorkin is so good that his worst crap is better than 90% of what other writers can put out and so I will still watch the show on occasion, but after The West Wing, Sports Night, The Social Network and even Studio 60, I'm disappointed by The Newsroom, especially after that powerhouse opening scene.
As for the scene itself, while the speech was great, it's going up against a bit of a strawman. Do American walk around all day assuming it as fact that the USA is the greatest country on Earth? Maybe it's because I live in a blue state, but I haven't seen the memo. Sure some jingoistic politicians talk about the US being a great country in between kissing babies, but is it really put forth in an intellectual capacity that needs refuting? I don't see it.
Anyway, defining "great" is really subjective. I'm sure some would define "great" as some combination of military strength and political influence, in which case the US certainly is the "greatest." There are other metrics also ignored by Jeff Daniels' character, such as scientific output and technological output that would probably also put the US on top. But again, that's all subjective and irrelevant anyway.