Go back
American Eugenics Movement

American Eugenics Movement

Debates

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22644
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

We Americans have some history many would like to forget, but Germany was not the first country to have a eugenics movement.

http://www.eugenicsarchive.org/eugenics/list3.pl

There was even a film that promoted forced sterilization called "Tomorrow's Children".



At what point is a policy considered eugenics? Some states do not allow marriage between cousins. Could that be considered eugenics? What if someone had a serious hereditary disease and had children knowing they would likely give that bad gene to their children? Is that ethical?

If someday gene therapy could cure hereditary diseases, should gene screening be mandatory for ethical reasons?

kmax87
Republicant Retiree

Blade Runner

Joined
09 Oct 04
Moves
107159
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Metal Brain
We Americans have some history many would like to forget, but Germany was not the first country to have a eugenics movement.

http://www.eugenicsarchive.org/eugenics/list3.pl

There was even a film that promoted forced sterilization called "Tomorrow's Children".

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gWtBtMU9bMw

At what point is a policy considered eu ...[text shortened]... erapy could cure hereditary diseases, should gene screening be mandatory for ethical reasons?
To these and other similar hard to answer questions hire out GATACA from your local blockbuster. See the future today!

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22644
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by kmax87
To these and other similar hard to answer questions hire out GATACA from your local blockbuster. See the future today!
I saw that movie once.

Here is a good article called "Go ahead, kiss your cousin". It uses the inbred Rothschild family as an example with a family tree. It gives insight into why the inbreeding started in this wealthy banking family. It also shows which states don't allow marriage between cousins and a world map of countries that do it as well.

http://discovermagazine.com/2003/aug/featkiss

I learned a lot from it.

STS

Joined
07 Feb 07
Moves
62961
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Sterilizing retards is a good idea. Why would anyone think otherwise?

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22644
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sam The Sham
Sterilizing retards is a good idea. Why would anyone think otherwise?
Mentally handicapped people can have children with high IQs. I've seen it happen.

STS

Joined
07 Feb 07
Moves
62961
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Metal Brain
Mentally handicapped people can have children with high IQs. I've seen it happen.
Yes I'm sure you have, but who's going to raise them? Why would a severly retarded person be allowed to have children? The idea is insane.

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22644
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sam The Sham
Yes I'm sure you have, but who's going to raise them? Why would a severly retarded person be allowed to have children? The idea is insane.
You didn't say severely, and that has nothing to do with genetics.

Who would raise them is a different issue. What if only one parent is retarded?

I'm not promoting the procreation of retarded people, I'm just saying retardation does not necessarily mean there is anything wrong with the gene pool. It is often a developmental problem.

STS

Joined
07 Feb 07
Moves
62961
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Metal Brain
You didn't say severely, and that has nothing to do with genetics.

Who would raise them is a different issue. What if only one parent is retarded?

I'm not promoting the procreation of retarded people, I'm just saying retardation does not necessarily mean there is anything wrong with the gene pool. It is often a developmental problem.
I don't think you have any experiance with tards and don't know enough to form a valid opinion.

MB

Joined
07 Dec 05
Moves
22644
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sam The Sham
I don't think you have any experiance with tards and don't know enough to form a valid opinion.
I knew a guy that married a mentally handicapped woman and they had a boy. He was a smart and good looking young man that got good grades in school.

She wasn't retarded because of her genes. Some women drink while they are pregnant and that may be why she was born that way. You could make the argument that she may carry a gene of alcoholism but that is another issue.

no1marauder
Naturally Right

Somewhere Else

Joined
22 Jun 04
Moves
42677
Clock
16 Apr 09
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sam The Sham
I don't think you have any experiance with tards and don't know enough to form a valid opinion.
He's talking to you; that's a good way to gain "experiance with tards".

The shameful history of forced sterilization is shocking to anyone with a conscience (that wouldn't include you). Oddly enough, right wingers who scream about the excessive reach of government when it raises rich people's taxes don't seem to have a problem with the State determining who is too much of a "tard" to have children. Odd.

S
The Mullverine

Little Beirut

Joined
13 May 05
Moves
8481
Clock
16 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Sam The Sham
Yes I'm sure you have, but who's going to raise them? Why would a severly retarded person be allowed to have children? The idea is insane.
The fact that your bigoted self is allowed to have kids is what's insane.

jb

Joined
29 Mar 09
Moves
816
Clock
17 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Hitler got his eugenics ideas from the United States.

s
Granny

Parts Unknown

Joined
19 Jan 07
Moves
73159
Clock
17 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by joe beyser
Hitler got his eugenics ideas from the United States.
And don't forget the bricks and cement he used to construct the ovens. They came from the US also. FACT.

GRANNY.

kmax87
Republicant Retiree

Blade Runner

Joined
09 Oct 04
Moves
107159
Clock
17 Apr 09
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by smw6869
And don't forget the bricks and cement he used to construct the ovens. They came from the US also. FACT.

GRANNY.
What next? The designs for the ovens were tried and tested age old designs that had been used for centuries by Europe's goldsmiths and other metallurgists? And no doubt it was all financed by ..............

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.