Go back
Are Americans Geographically illiterate?

Are Americans Geographically illiterate?

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
I wonder how many Saudi Arabians know where in the US New York is.
How many can name the capitol of Iowa? Or know which state the Mississippi River begins in? Or know which city was smashed by derechos on Labor Day weekend of 1999, causing damage that took weeks to clean up and brought in help from another nation? There are a zillion things happening all the time. People can't learn it all. They learn what they think is important to them.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by pawnhandler
How many can name the capitol of Iowa? Or know which state the Mississippi River begins in? Or know which city was smashed by derechos on Labor Day weekend of 1999, causing damage that took weeks to clean up and brought in help from another nation? There are a zillion things happening all the time. People can't learn it all. They learn what they think is important to them.
Bear in mind that the age bracket here is 18 to 24. It says something of the state of education, with geography being a pretty standard part of every curriculum (unless you come from North Korea), that people this young cannot remember such simple things as 'where the country we are at war'... sorry.. I mean 'where the country we are establishing peace in is'.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HumeA
Bear in mind that the age bracket here is 18 to 24. It says something of the state of education, with geography being a pretty standard part of every curriculum (unless you come from North Korea), that people this young cannot remember such simple things as 'where the country we are at war'... sorry.. I mean 'where the country we are establishing peace in is'.
What does it say about the state of education? That kids can't be bothered to memorize facts they can find in 2 seconds on a map?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lepomis
What does it say about the state of education? That kids can't be bothered to memorize facts they can find in 2 seconds on a map?
How about that kids aren't learning what they are supposed to be. I'm not saying that geography should be on the curriculum... simply that the system isn't working.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HumeA
How about that kids aren't learning what they are supposed to be. I'm not saying that geography should be on the curriculum... simply that the system isn't working.
Is it the systems fault or the students/parents fault?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by lepomis
Is it the systems fault or the students/parents fault?
Whoever's fault it is, it's not working particularly well, is it? The system in my mind = the means by which children gain their education. It doesn't matter who is at fault... it's not working.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HumeA
Whoever's fault it is, it's not working particularly well, is it? The system in my mind = the means by which children gain their education. It doesn't matter who is at fault... it's not working.
I would say that the system works for a very large amount of students... The ones that it fails will fill the low skilled labor jobs. We can not have everyone toting around a degree.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HumeA
How about that kids aren't learning what they are supposed to be. I'm not saying that geography should be on the curriculum... simply that the system isn't working.
For one thing, we spend that money on sex-ed for 3rd graders and can't afford to waste time on stupid stuff like Geography.

Gotta have your priorities straight first.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by jammer
For one thing, we spend that money on sex-ed for 3rd graders and can't afford to waste time on stupid stuff like Geography.

Gotta have your priorities straight first.
I tutor 3rd graders. They study geography. They don't study sex-ed.

It seems your bizaare hatred of California and it's educational system is not based on fact.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by AThousandYoung
I tutor 3rd graders. They study geography. They don't study sex-ed.

It seems your bizaare hatred of California and it's educational system is not based on fact.
Love California .. hate what people like yourself have done to the teaching profession.

Are you a Union man?

Why is it that Calif school teachers won't agree to random drug testing?

Sitting on secret are you?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by HumeA
Bear in mind that the age bracket here is 18 to 24. It says something of the state of education, with geography being a pretty standard part of every curriculum (unless you come from North Korea), that people this young cannot remember such simple things as 'where the country we are at war'... sorry.. I mean 'where the country we are establishing peace in is'.
I addressed this four pages back, actually. :'(

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by jammer
Love California .. hate what people like yourself have done to the teaching profession.

Are you a Union man?

Why is it that Calif school teachers won't agree to random drug testing?

Sitting on secret are you?
Does your job require random drug testing?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by pawnhandler
Does your job require random drug testing?
Yes, my profession has much more integrity than school teachers .. i'm a poker dealer.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by jammer
Yes, my profession has much more integrity than school teachers .. i'm a poker dealer.
How does dealing poker involve more integrity? What exactly do you know about school teachers?

Vote Up
Vote Down

don't trust any poll for which the pollters refuse to pay the pollees a decent wage. ESPECIALLY if you're polling youngsters.