Go back
Best states ranking

Best states ranking

Debates

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
02 Mar 18
3 edits

https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings

Three things that struck me as interesting:

1. In fiscal stability, the top 13 states are all Trump states. Obviously, it's because red states have lower spending on social welfare programs, but it seemingly also means that blue states don't have the discipline to tax enough to support their spending. This is especially true in California, where they want to spend a lot on social welfare programs, but have insane constitutional limitations on their ability to raise money through taxation.

2. It's interesting that the northeast dominates in crime and correction. Even New York with big, bad NYC, is top 10.

3. The top SIXTEEN in healthcare have adopted the ACA ("Obamacare" ) Medicaid expansion. All 18 states that have not are in the bottom 34 in healthcare.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
02 Mar 18
1 edit

Note that California could only make #32 in spite of its 4th ranked economy. IMO, economy ought to be the best correlated with over-all, though it would take a lot of work to put together a spreadsheet to figure out which ones do correlate best.

This is another indication of the ungovernable nature of the state, which we debated a few weeks ago.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
02 Mar 18

Originally posted by @sh76
Note that California could only make #32 in spite of its 4th ranked economy. IMO, economy ought to be the best correlated with over-all, though it would take a lot of work to put together a spreadsheet to figure out which ones do correlate best.

This is another indication of the ungovernable nature of the state, which we debated a few weeks ago.
Interestingly, the only state with a similar variance between economy and over-all is Texas, another enormous state.

Ashiitaka

RSA

Joined
20 Oct 16
Moves
11569
Clock
02 Mar 18
1 edit

Originally posted by @sh76
https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings

Three things that struck me as interesting:

1. In fiscal stability, the top 13 states are all Trump states. Obviously, it's because red states have lower spending on social welfare programs, but it seemingly also means that blue states don't have the discipline to tax enough to support their spending. This ...[text shortened]... Obamacare" ) Medicaid expansion. All 18 states that have not are in the bottom 34 in healthcare.
Here is my opinion, and take it with a pinch of salt since I have never set foot in the mainland U.S.
Puerto Rico doesn't count.

As do most foreigners, I feel the pull of America sometimes. There's just so much wealth, culture, opportunity and of course, natural beauty. I mean, America looks stunning. South Africa is #1 in terms of beauty but it has so many other issues. America is definitely #2 in the world for best natural beauty, I mean, you have it all. The beaches of California, the redwood forests, Yosemite, crater lake, the rainy, temperate state of Washington, Yellowstone, the Badlands, the Utah desert, grand canyon, skiing in Colorado, the Rockies, the bayou, charming New England, Alaska and of course, Hawaii.
Thanks, Teddy Roosevelt!

There is, of course, the political situation at the moment and the fact that I will return to the UK at some point and probably stay there. I do love America, though, for all my criticism of it. Being the world leader comes with responsibility. I think this wobbly phase is just a blip in history and America will work through it. From an outsider's perspective, the U.S presidency looks like a pretty weak office anyway.

If I was to move to America, I would live in any of the western states, Minnesota, Massachusetts or New York. NYC is wonderful according to all my friends who have been there. One of my good friends studies at Columbia. He is 100% South African and has only lived in NYC since September 2017 for school, and he already considers America home. He's only been there for 6 months! It must be quite nice.

w

Joined
02 Jan 06
Moves
12857
Clock
02 Mar 18
1 edit

Originally posted by @sh76
https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings

Three things that struck me as interesting:

1. In fiscal stability, the top 13 states are all Trump states. Obviously, it's because red states have lower spending on social welfare programs, but it seemingly also means that blue states don't have the discipline to tax enough to support their spending. This ...[text shortened]... Obamacare" ) Medicaid expansion. All 18 states that have not are in the bottom 34 in healthcare.
Fox news ranks California has having the worst quality of life in the US

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2018/03/01/california-has-worst-quality-life-in-us-study-says.html

With all the homelessness and rampant illegal immigration and high taxation, and drug abuse and defecating in the streets, it's not hard to see why.

sh76
Civis Americanus Sum

New York

Joined
26 Dec 07
Moves
17585
Clock
02 Mar 18

Originally posted by @ashiitaka
Here is my opinion, and take it with a pinch of salt since I have never set foot in the mainland U.S.
Puerto Rico doesn't count.

As do most foreigners, I feel the pull of America sometimes. There's just so much wealth, culture, opportunity and of course, natural beauty. I mean, America looks stunning. South Africa is #1 in terms of beauty but it ha ...[text shortened]... and he already considers America home. He's only been there for 6 months! It must be quite nice.
I have certain family and community restrictions keeping me in NY, but if those weren't considerations, I'd probably end up in Wisconsin or Minnesota for natural beauty, good government, centralized location and other reasons.

Then again, I don't mind the cold. Most people would veto both states based on weather alone.

w

Joined
02 Jan 06
Moves
12857
Clock
02 Mar 18

Originally posted by @sh76
I have certain family and community restrictions keeping me in NY, but if those weren't considerations, I'd probably end up in Wisconsin or Minnesota for natural beauty, good government, centralized location and other reasons.

Then again, I don't mind the cold. Most people would veto both states based on weather alone.
Get out of looneyville while you still can sh! 😲

AThousandYoung
1st Dan TKD Kukkiwon

tinyurl.com/2te6yzdu

Joined
23 Aug 04
Moves
26758
Clock
02 Mar 18
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by @sh76
https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings

Three things that struck me as interesting:

1. In fiscal stability, the top 13 states are all Trump states. Obviously, it's because red states have lower spending on social welfare programs, but it seemingly also means that blue states don't have the discipline to tax enough to support their spending. This ...[text shortened]... Obamacare" ) Medicaid expansion. All 18 states that have not are in the bottom 34 in healthcare.
THESE are the five best States in the Union?!

#1
Iowa
#2
Minnesota
#3
Utah
#4
North Dakota
#5
New Hampshire

mchill
Cryptic

Behind the scenes

Joined
27 Jun 16
Moves
3283
Clock
03 Mar 18

Originally posted by @sh76
Note that California could only make #32 in spite of its 4th ranked economy. IMO, economy ought to be the best correlated with over-all, though it would take a lot of work to put together a spreadsheet to figure out which ones do correlate best.

This is another indication of the ungovernable nature of the state, which we debated a few weeks ago.
NY is better than they've been given credit for, I only have 2 minor pet peeves about the New Yorkers. They insist on mispronouncing Nevada (see clip for lesson on how to do it right!) and most are only dimly aware that there are other states on the West Coast besides California. These aside, New York is the most underrated state there is.

K

Germany

Joined
27 Oct 08
Moves
3118
Clock
03 Mar 18

Originally posted by @sh76
Note that California could only make #32 in spite of its 4th ranked economy. IMO, economy ought to be the best correlated with over-all, though it would take a lot of work to put together a spreadsheet to figure out which ones do correlate best.

This is another indication of the ungovernable nature of the state, which we debated a few weeks ago.
When the difference is between, on average, making a lot of money and making a huge amount of money (historically speaking), that is not going to be decisive for the quality of life. Finland for example would be miles ahead of any U.S. state despite having a lower GDP per capita than many of them.

Shallow Blue

Joined
18 Jan 07
Moves
12477
Clock
05 Mar 18

Originally posted by @sh76
1. In fiscal stability, the top 13 states are all Trump states. Obviously, it's because red states have lower spending on social welfare programs, but it seemingly also means that blue states don't have the discipline to tax enough to support their spending. This is especially true in California, where they want to spend a lot on social welfare programs, but have insane constitutional limitations on their ability to raise money through taxation.
I suspect you have it backward here.

Rich areas all over the world predominantly vote right-wing, regardless of whether taxation policy is set at their level or above their heads. Those are also the regions which can afford to be easy with the taxes and strict with support for their less fortunate inhabitants.

w

Joined
02 Jan 06
Moves
12857
Clock
08 Mar 18
3 edits



So it costs San Fran about $30 million a year to clean the streets from drug needles and human feces, but they say the problem is they can't afford a shelter for the homeless that costs about $25 million?

Makes sense to me.

NBC covered this? Shocking! 😲

Philokalia

S. Korea

Joined
03 Jun 17
Moves
41191
Clock
09 Mar 18

Originally posted by @ashiitaka
Here is my opinion, and take it with a pinch of salt since I have never set foot in the mainland U.S.
Puerto Rico doesn't count.

As do most foreigners, I feel the pull of America sometimes. There's just so much wealth, culture, opportunity and of course, natural beauty. I mean, America looks stunning. South Africa is #1 in terms of beauty but it ha ...[text shortened]... and he already considers America home. He's only been there for 6 months! It must be quite nice.
For natural beauty, I have it on good word that Norway and Turkey are the top.

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.