Go back
British Soldiers detained by Iranians

British Soldiers detained by Iranians

Debates

Vote Up
Vote Down

Do you think the bristish really crossed the borders and is the stand taken by the iranians justified. What do you think they want in return for the 15 soldiers.?

Will Tony Blair bow down in front of the Iranians listening to their terms & conditions ?

Is some guerilla warfare eminent by the british troops to free their boys ?

If italians were in the same boat i m sure they would have done some heroic things ?

Vote Up
Vote Down

?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rohitmalde
Do you think the bristish really crossed the borders
I don't know.

Where is the UK government supposed to have got their GPS evidence from?
The Iranians have the GPS units from the sailors boats, and I thought the helicopter had gone back to the Cornwall, and the Cornwall was supposed to be too far away to support them.
If the Cornwall could see them on radar (dunno if they could see something that small and non-metallic), then they should have seen the Iranians coming.

So how do we know where they were?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rohitmalde
Do you think the bristish really crossed the borders and is the stand taken by the iranians justified. What do you think they want in return for the 15 soldiers.?
British sailors released as 'a gift' from Iran. Admission of guilt by the Iranian regime?

Vote Up
Vote Down

The Mouse That Roared, crappy little countries screaming for recognition by creating international emergencies. They're like small children that don't know the difference between good attention and bad attention.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ElleEffSeee
British sailors released as 'a gift' from Iran. Admission of guilt by the Iranian regime?
Or has the UK given them something behind the scenes, diplomatically?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by aging blitzer
Or has the UK given them something behind the scenes, diplomatically?
Like a nuclear bomb?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by aging blitzer
Or has the UK given them something behind the scenes, diplomatically?
A night of passion with the Queen?!?!?!?!

😲

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by aging blitzer
I don't know.

Where is the UK government supposed to have got their GPS evidence from?
The Iranians have the GPS units from the sailors boats, and I thought the helicopter had gone back to the Cornwall, and the Cornwall was supposed to be too far away to support them.
If the Cornwall could see them on radar (dunno if they could see something that ...[text shortened]... etallic), then they should have seen the Iranians coming.

So how do we know where they were?
.... and how do the Iranians know where they were ?

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by aging blitzer
I don't know.

Where is the UK government supposed to have got their GPS evidence from?
The Iranians have the GPS units from the sailors boats, and I thought the helicopter had gone back to the Cornwall, and the Cornwall was supposed to be too far away to support them.
If the Cornwall could see them on radar (dunno if they could see something that ...[text shortened]... etallic), then they should have seen the Iranians coming.

So how do we know where they were?
Those GPS units were relaying their position back to the ship so the Brits have the records. I didn't know Iran had the unit. All I had heard was that the signal went dead.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ElleEffSeee
Like a nuclear bomb?
We can barely afford to rent them from the US.
Where do you think we'd get a spare one from?

1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rohitmalde
Do you think the bristish really crossed the borders and is the stand taken by the iranians justified. What do you think they want in return for the 15 soldiers.?

Will Tony Blair bow down in front of the Iranians listening to their terms & conditions ?

Is some guerilla warfare eminent by the british troops to free their boys ?

If italians were in the same boat i m sure they would have done some heroic things ?
The Iranians will use this incident in their overall battle against the United Nations Security Council. The Iranians are very clever and skillful negotiaters and they will try to get the most out of this situation, be it economically, diplomatically or politically. They will use this hostage taking to degrade the British government over and over again and they will try and force the Brits on their knees.

I'm afraid this is going to be a very long and for the British a very degrading and painful diplomatic exercise.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Merk
Those GPS units were relaying their position back to the ship so the Brits have the records.
ah OK, I now see the BBC say

"One of the small boats used by the boarding party from HMS Cornwall had a GPS chart plotter, continually communicating its position to HMS Cornwall, where the position was displayed on an electronic chart.
The UK says the two boats were together at all times."

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by ivanhoe
The Iranians will use this incident in their overall battle against the United Nations Security Council. The Iranians are very clever and skillful negotiaters and they will try to get the most out of this situation, be it economically, diplomatically or politically. They will use this hostage taking to degrade the British government over and over again and t ...[text shortened]... s going to be a very long and for the British a very degrading and painful diplomatic exercise.
How will they be able to do that with the sailors back in British hands? I'd expect the sailors to report how they were coerced into admissions of guilt when they get back, even if the British government does not say as much.

Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by Seitse
A night of passion with the Queen?!?!?!?!

😲
maybe this Iranian diplomat
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/6522113.stm