Go back
Cremation VS Burial

Cremation VS Burial

Debates

r

Over seas

Joined
20 Oct 01
Moves
14169
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

My nieghbor was telling me that if you are creamated (being christian) you cannot get into heaven, according to the canon of the Church.
Is that right?

r

Over seas

Joined
20 Oct 01
Moves
14169
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

When I go I will be cremated and dumped into the mississippi river. I cant stand the idea of being put in a box and buried; it gives me the creeps.
This all came up when I was talking with her about her sons friend being creamated after he died. He was concerned he was not going to make it in. It was ironic. He was kicked out of the hells angels, because he was not good for their immage. Anyway, I digress.

Mike

rwingett
Ming the Merciless

Royal Oak, MI

Joined
09 Sep 01
Moves
27626
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rapalla7
My nieghbor was telling me that if you are creamated (being christian) you cannot get into heaven, according to the canon of the Church.
Is that right?
Buried, cremated, what does it matter? RBHill is the only one who is ever going to heaven.

F
mmm.....burgers

Joined
07 Oct 03
Moves
5823
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

You don't want to go listening to those christians. They only quote the bits in the bible that they want to believe are there and ignore the rest.

*light fuse and retreat*

r

Over seas

Joined
20 Oct 01
Moves
14169
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

At the funeral I was delightfully suprise to hear the F word spoken from the Catholic pulpit. I found it very entertaining. I watched the father slide under the pew in front of him.😵

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89788
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rapalla7
My nieghbor was telling me that if you are creamated (being christian) you cannot get into heaven, according to the canon of the Church.
Is that right?
Surely the church doesn't have a stance on cremation?
Is no bastion of civilisation safe from these bloody freaks?

anyways: cremation is cheaper.
here in Holland you have to rent a plot for 10 years if you want to bury somone and after that said 10 they get dug up and cremated anyways...

s

England

Joined
15 Nov 03
Moves
33497
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Roman Catholic docterine does not accept cremation, but the going to hell bit is priests who frighten the worshers, with there veiws.

shavixmir
Lord

Sewers of Holland

Joined
31 Jan 04
Moves
89788
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by stoker
Roman Catholic docterine does not accept cremation, but the going to hell bit is priests who frighten the worshers, with there veiws.
I know lots of Roman Catholics. I've never heard 1 of them suggest that cremation leads to hell damnation.

s

England

Joined
15 Nov 03
Moves
33497
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

as i stated its not to my knowledge in the doctrine but is given some creadence by priests , so ask them

i

Felicific Forest

Joined
15 Dec 02
Moves
49434
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rapalla7
My nieghbor was telling me that if you are creamated (being christian) you cannot get into heaven, according to the canon of the Church.
Is that right?

It is non-sense.

i

Felicific Forest

Joined
15 Dec 02
Moves
49434
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by stoker
Roman Catholic docterine does not accept cremation, but the going to hell bit is priests who frighten the worshers, with there veiws.

Roman Catholic teachings accept cremation.

r

Over seas

Joined
20 Oct 01
Moves
14169
Clock
15 Jul 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

A. The practice of burying the body goes back to early Christian times. For centuries cremation was expressly forbidden in the Church because of the belief that the body is the temple of the Holy Sprit, as well as the belief in the resurrection of the body. Cremation was seen as a pagan practice that denied the doctrine of the Resurrection

In 1963, the Vatican lifted the ban on cremation for Catholics. In doing so, the Church allowed cremation in certain circumstances provided the reasons for choosing it did not counter Christian belief.

However, no allowances were made for any prayer or rituals to be used with the cremated remains. This meant all funeral services were to occur in the presence of the body, with cremation taking place afterwards.

On March 21, 1997, this changed. The Vatican granted permission for the cremated remains of a body to be brought into church for the liturgical rites of burial. It is still, however, the Church's preference to have the full compliment of funeral rites take place with the body present and then have cremation afterwards.




Crap I am still screwed!😕

e

Joined
03 Dec 03
Moves
25735
Clock
15 Jul 04
1 edit
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by FatElvis
You don't want to go listening to those christians. They only quote the bits in the bible that they want to believe are there and ignore the rest.

*light fuse and retreat*
after all....it is "ashes to ashes"
My brother died almost five years ago. We are taking his ahses to the ocean in a week to scatter them. sigh....:'(

R
Godless Commie

Glasgow

Joined
06 Jan 04
Moves
171019
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Originally posted by rapalla7
My nieghbor was telling me that if you are creamated (being christian) you cannot get into heaven, according to the canon of the Church.
Is that right?
I'm not really too bothered about the Church's view, but I was surprised to find that burial is considered better for the environment than cremation.

kirksey957
Outkast

With White Women

Joined
31 Jul 01
Moves
91452
Clock
15 Jul 04
Vote Up
Vote Down

Even cheaper than cremation is the option of donating your body to a medical school for study. They will eventually cremate you. Cost: $0

Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.