Originally posted by Melanerpes
But what is it that "convinces" people of the merits of a given political philosophy?
Why is it that after much time is spent debating on various issues, it seems like no one's position on anything ever really changes very much? The right wingers are just as right-wing as before - the left-wingers are just as left-wing as before, and those in the middl ...[text shortened]... here - my position has totally changed on that issue". But this never seems to happen.
So what you are asking is the quesiton that stumps us all, namely, what contributes to a belief system or erradicates one?
I think for any belief system there needs to be evidence. The more evidence the more "faith" you have in something. For example, suppose someone walked up to you and said that there is a pink elephant in your back yard. You would think him to be mad, right? However, what if someone else walked up to you and said the same thing? Perhaps you might think that they are both mad or maybe playing a practical joke on you. However, the more this persists the more you will begin to question your own sanity and sense of reality, assuming, of course, you don't see the pink elephant.
Having said that, perhaps if they say there is a real elephant in your backyard. It might be more believable to think this since you have no basis to believe that pink elephants exist. You see, the more belief systems you violate the harder it is to begin to believe.